KMC Comic Book Tiers

Started by Priest485 pages

Originally posted by SpunkySmurph
For the asia thing, as well as some city-destroying feats, check out X-Man #70. And, at his peak, he IS DP level, but he would burn himself out. It was also stated that if all his energy went into an explosion, he would take out a very large piece of existence.

Mid-herald level my ass...


Ill vote to bump him to high herald...

Originally posted by Priest
after that i think we should bump him DOWN to Low Herald 😈

2 votes to move down J'onn.

Didn't Nate lose to Hulk? His power seems there, I'm just not convinced because of his win-loss ratio. What's his most impressive victory? Holocaust?

And saying you'd wipe out existence and actually doing it are 2 very different things. Comics are filled with constant hyperbole.

For example, if you went to the vs. forum and made a Cpt. Marvel(DC)/Orion/etc. vs. Nate Grey, chances are it would be mixed results, and a lot would say Nate would lose. And all those people are mid.

*rapping on backyard window from outside*

Suggestion:

1. Make a list of all the characters with uncertain/controversial placement.

2. Set up poll threads and let more KMC members vote. I mean, as reasonable and wise as you guys are 🤣 , letting the general KMC body vote could help to settle the thornier placements.

3. Does this mean a lot of poll threads? Maybe. So what? Is there a thread limit? Does it mean fanboys get to throw in their 0.5 cents worth? Who cares? There will be many voting who are not fanboys. Hey, worse comes to worse, you tried the Poll Approach and it didn't work: you're no worse off than before.

I'm just saying, seems to me you guys are constructing this major, potentially useful, hierarchal reference that you likely expect everyone to acknowledge...yet most of KMC has no say in it.

*runs away before someone can throw a tomato*

Your suggestions anger me.

Polls don't work. Past tourneys, and some of the random idiocy that went on, is proof of that.

We have a good system and anyone who wants to contribute to the debate, can.

polls wouldent work, guys Martian Mind would create 20 billion accounts to bump their favorite charcter up a spot. 😛

Your suggestions anger me.

😕 (I knew I'd get a tomato.) No offense was meant.

Polls don't work. Past tourneys, and some of the random idiocy that went on, is proof of that.
That's too bad. Just seemed like a logical way to maybe resolve some of the tougher placements.

polls wouldent work, guys Martian Mind would create 20 billion accounts to bump their favorite charcter up a spot.
Gadzooks. Hadn't thought of that.

Originally posted by Mindship
😕 (I knew I'd get a tomato.) No offense was meant.

I give you several tomatoes. Roger Clemens fastball style.

Originally posted by Validus
2 votes to move down J'onn.

Three.

Also; this ain't no damn democracy.

Most people aren't as knowledgeable as the few people here who put in the most effort. Vally knows what he's talking about. Digi knows what he's talking about (sometimes).

xmeat? Rutog? Martian Mind?

They're off their ****ing rocker! We don't need their input, 😛.

Hey,Hey F*ck you.I logically debated and am entitled to my opinion.

Originally posted by Martian_mind
Hey,Hey F*ck you.I logically debated and am entitled to my opinion.

You're a fan of J'onn and Australian.

'Nuff said.

😛.

*
*
*
<--- back to playing in the yard...where it's cold, and dark...

Hehe. I'll put my vote for keeping J'onn where he is. We give MM enough crap for his Martian fetish.

Originally posted by Soljer
Also; this ain't no damn democracy.

Most people aren't as knowledgeable as the few people here who put in the most effort.

Excellent point though. I make no claims to knowing a ton, but there's definitely people who shouldn't be contributing much to this.

Originally posted by Evil_Ash
🙄

And of course you have to make a stupid Apoc comment...

Annihilus gets beasted by the Fantastic Four all the time, yet he can one-shot Thor?

Just saying, you know, Thor can beat Apoc, and Annihilus can one-shot Thor...

So, pre-tell, how does Annihilus lose to the Fabulous Four?
Also, that was through the cosmic rod.

Originally posted by Soljer
You're a fan of J'onn and Australian.

'Nuff said.

😛.

I may be that but dammit all i have more heart then Thing.Do you know how much shit i've been copping around here latley since this crusade?and have i given up?No.

My opinion is valid and i am highly knowledgeable.....even if i have bad-taste.

I think everyone in the Mid Herald group except MM should be bumped up to High Herald.

Originally posted by DigiMark007
Hehe. I'll put my vote for keeping J'onn where he is. We give MM enough crap for his Martian fetish.

Excellent point though. I make no claims to knowing a ton, but there's definitely people who shouldn't be contributing much to this.

You may not know a ton, but you are smart enough to keep your mouth shut when you don't.

Most don't have the same reservations.

Originally posted by Martian_mind
I may be that but dammit all i have more heart then Thing.Do you know how much shit i've been copping around here latley since this crusade?and have i given up?No.

My opinion is valid and i am highly knowledgeable.....even if i have bad-taste.

And the whole australian thing...