Red Nemesis
The Blind Critic
There is so much wrong with this. I don't even know what I should start with. I suppose I will go in chronological order, but for the next post I will try to go in descending order from the most skewed to the least.
Originally posted by Quincy Jones
Well, yeah. You said it yourself. Jesus wolud have had to be a liar if there is no truth behind Christianity. But look at it this way: most liars are cowards, and they would never die, let alone undergo 6 hours of torture, for what they believe in.
Why does he have to be a liar? I presume that you are attempting to use the great C.S. Lewis's "Mad, Bad, or God" routine. The problem with that argument is that it creates a false trichotomy. Is it so impossible that he was simply mistaken?
Originally posted by Quincy Jones
If I were to compare the ultimate Christian to the ultimate atheist, I would say it comes down to Martin Luthor King and Marilyn Manson. I leave it to you to decide which of the two most right-thinking people would like to emulate.
These are case studies, and no judgement of the whole can be made on their basis alone. What if I made the comparrison between Thomas Jefferson (who was at
most a deist) and one of the countless child molesters in the Catholic Church, or one of the Spanish Inquisitors who killed people in yahwe's name, or one of the Conquistadors, or a Crusader, or... I could go on. That there are bad atheists does not make
all atheists bad. Nor does the presence of immoral (by today's standards- lets not get into cultural relativity) Christians make
all Christians bad.
Originally posted by Quincy Jones
Its ok if you want to fool yourself, but dont try to fool others by saying false things about the greatest Man who ever lived.
Who was talking about Abraham Lincoln? Besides, I don't think that anyone was being disingenuous here- who was trying to fool anyone?
Originally posted by Quincy Jones
By the way, I dont like george bush and i dont think he is a real Christian.
So no one you like gets to be a
real Christian? Congrats- You are now yahwe. Doesn't the Bible say "judge not, lest ye yourself be judged?" (Or something to that effect?)