Luke VS Obi

Who would win

For me this is a tought call Obi was a really good Jedi so was Luke. Thought call for me.

What Luke and what Kenobi? At what time in their "careers"?

Any time in there careers

That's too vague; you have to be specific. Obi-Wan in ROTS would have obliterated Luke in ESB, but Luke in the LOTF would eat ANH Obi-Wan alive.

Originally posted by Captain REX
That's too vague; you have to be specific. Obi-Wan in ROTS would have obliterated Luke in ESB, but Luke in the LOTF would eat ANH Obi-Wan alive.

You took the words right out of my mouth Captain Rex.

[Hijack Thread] Okay, TPM, AOTC, ROTS, and ANH Kenobi versus ROTJ and DE Luke.[/Hijack Thread]

ROTS Obi-Wan > ANH, ESB, ROTJ Luke
ATOC Obi-Wan >? ROTJ Luke
TPM =? ROTJ Luke

NJO Luke > any Obi-Wan

Luke takes this.

ROTJ Luke > AOTC Obi-Wan, TPM Obi-Wan.

He defeated Vader after all.

DE Luke >>> any version of Kenobi.

I have a sneaking suspicion that DOYLEZOMBIE isn't the Star Wars nerd we all are.

Is that a bad thing, he has a life at least.

I find time for both.

Just don't tell my life. She's a jealous one.

Which Luke and which Obi-Wan is this?

All I can say is that if the Luke is any Luke AFTER the OT starting with DE then he'll beat any version of Kenobi to date. If its any of the OT Luke's vs. whatever Kenobi then Luke will lose.

So Post-OT Luke over ALL Kenobi's

and ALL Kenobi's over any OT Luke.