Did the Confederacy Really Lose?

Started by Alliance6 pages

O.o

o.O

Still EU though.

Concrete EU.

So no go here.

Such a limitation would be a detrimentla limitation on an otherwise valid conversation. I see no problem with a logical extrapolation based on repeated efforts from Lucasfilm.

Can we not claim that Han was alive between Episodes V and IV because that was not shown in the movies? Its a logical assumption, despite technically being EU.

No, it's logical because he's alive in IV and in V.... ergo, he's alive between the two. You don't need EU sources to talk about that, the canon provides enough info for that particular (all be it senseless) subject.

And you can continue the debate, in the EU forum.

Therefore, no ECD's were used. 313

Originally posted by queeq
No, it's logical because he's alive in IV and in V.... ergo, he's alive between the two. You don't need EU sources to talk about that, the canon provides enough info for that particular (all be it senseless) subject.

And you can continue the debate, in the EU forum.

What if he died and was brought back to life?

Honestly, you can't say.

*sigh* No..... but since no reference was made to any such thing happening in the canon sources, there's no need to discuss it. He could have been chewing chewing gum, had a pedicure, shaved his favourite poodle and have become the greatest cocktail maker in the universe: it doesn't matter because tehre's nothing to substantiate that, nor does it have any bearing on the story.

Indeedy, EU has no place in a discussion here...

The Confederacy lost, it's not really a matter of how clonetroopers killed the droids, we just know that they did, and that's all we need to know for the movies...

Amen

😒

Hehehehe

Rebel scum.

Where?

In this very thread...no doubt plotting some subversive act of destruction.

Originally posted by Alliance
What if he died and was brought back to life?

Honestly, you can't say.

it shouldnt have gone this far.
i just lost all respect for you schmoll

You had any then?

well..........you see................................*leaves*