Darth Vader (OT) or Anakin Skywalker (PT)

When he was fully submerged in the Dark Side on Mustafar, Anakin as played by Christenson was the best Anakin. It was his eyes that made him look so sinister, and in simple appearances, it's this Vader that looks evil. Suit-Vader doesn't really have that evil look, but he's way more badass looking/sounding.

Well Hayden can't hope to live up to the legendary James Earl Jones in the awesome voice category but I think he still delivered some good lines.

"I have brought peace, freedom, justice and secuirty to my new empire!"

Even the "whiny" lines some peole hate, I enjoyed.
Padme: You're not all powerful.
Well, I should be! Some day I will be... I will be the most powerful Jedi ever."

You liked Hayden's performance, didn't you Advent? Beyond his smokin' bod of course.

I liked those lines with Padme, he seemed genuinely distressed.

Originally posted by Luminatus

From a character standpoint, one is full of personality and the other isn't. In terms of appearance, I love the black armor but this is way cooler.

disagree. hayden christiansan is cute. but not with that make-up.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
When he was fully submerged in the Dark Side on Mustafar, Anakin as played by Christenson was the best Anakin. It was his eyes that made him look so sinister, and in simple appearances, it's this Vader that looks evil.

Originally posted by WO Polaski

disagree. hayden christiansan is cute. but not with that make-up.

Uh...what? He is cute but that's not why i prefer his ROTS look. I like his look because of the hair, eyes and outfit.

because theyre yellow or because he has eye shadow?

the outfit isnt all that imo. a glorifed leather dress doesnt compete with black leather. plus vaders voice is all that. i think the first time i truly had an orgasm was when when i first heard vader interrogate that rebel then throw him against the wall in A New Hope. anakin crying in return of the sith and moping in attack of the clones cant compare.

Originally posted by Luminatus
Well Hayden can't hope to live up to the legendary James Earl Jones in the awesome voice category but I think he still delivered some good lines.

"I have brought peace, freedom, justice and secuirty to my new empire!"

Even the "whiny" lines some peole hate, I enjoyed.
Padme: You're not all powerful.
Well, I should be! Some day I will be... I will be the most powerful Jedi ever."

You liked Hayden's performance, didn't you Advent? Beyond his smokin' bod of course.

Yeah, I believe AotC was the first time I'd seen him act, and I thought he played the part well in both movies. Especially on Mustafar after he killed the Seperatists, he was crying and the way Hayden looked at that point was perfect at that moment, you could tell that Anakin felt remorse about what he had done and become, but felt there was nothing he could do about it. He was great!

Originally posted by WO Polaski

disagree. hayden christiansan is cute. but not with that make-up.

LMFAO! 😆

because theyre yellow or because he has eye shadow?

The yellow but I could care less if he wears eye shadow.

Originally posted by Luminatus
The yellow but I could care less if he wears eye shadow.

*shrug* if youre into that kind of guy.

i like my men manly and stereotypically masculine. 🙂 its a weakness.

LMFAO! 😆

its pretty obvious where they got the inspiration for anakins attire in rots. 😛