Tangible God
Lets all love Lain
Revan did not "fall" to the Darkside, so Vapaad won't be as awesome here.
Revan never speaks, which is awesome. Mace is a badass, which is awesome.
Revan makes for a good marketing ploy, which is capitalistically awesome. Mace's very existence is to appeal to the younger generations who like "hip" Jedi, and to the older generations who remember Pulp Fiction, which is awesome.
Mace got killed tooled by a punk, which is not awesome, but also by Palpatine, who is awesome. Revan tooled everyone, which is awesome.
Revan's name sounds awesome, Mace's name reminds me of police brutality, which is awesomely necessary in some cities.
Revan, for all intents and purposes is white, which is awesome. Mace is the only black Jedi on the Council, which is discrimination on Yoda's part.
Revan wins.