potc4 without jack?

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/entertainment/2007-05/11/content_870578.htm
that would be terrible.
*nothing to say*

they wouldnt make it without Depp. I heard he would do it if the script was good. If anyone would be cut out, it would be Will and Liz. Their story is pretty much over.

Originally posted by allofyousuckkk
they wouldnt make it without Depp. I heard he would do it if the script was good. If anyone would be cut out, it would be Will and Liz. Their story is pretty much over.

Ya, but their son still has one hell of a story to tell I bet.

If jack does find the fountain of youth. maybe he will be around forever and since the next will be a spin off, maybe it would be about Wills son. Then, Will son would be all grown up and we would still have Jack, not to mention, Will won't really be going anywhere since he is captain of the dutchman. The only one who really wouldn't fit anywhere is Liz, and I still want her in it though.

Of it is a spin off, I hope its about Wills son.

POTC without Jack - NOT POTC.

yeah. without capt. jack... there's no pirates of the caribbean.
half the fans they have now probably wouldn't show up to the opening.

that would be a very sad day. :[

and what happened to johnny saying he'd do pirate movies for the next 10 years of his career!? bahh. i hope he was misquoted. :[

ever heard about the movie, The Rum Diary? Johnny was supposed to go out in there.. Rum - Pirates.... lol, it goes a long way..

that's true. i guess "pirate movies" doesnt actually mean PotC.
dang. well now i'm extra sad. lol.

aww... no worries...

without Jack, Pirates of the Caribbean would've been 'just another pirate movie'...

Originally posted by JaehSkywalker
aww... no worries...

without Jack, Pirates of the Caribbean would've been 'just another pirate movie'...

I would probably still go to see it if jack wasn't there, but I know I really wouldn't like it much.

Originally posted by Arachnid1
I would probably still go to see it if jack wasn't there, but I know I really wouldn't like it much.

yeah.... me too.. maybe.. but... IMO still without Jack, not POTC. He separated POTC from other 'just another pirate movie's...

year. i would see it, too. but i won't buy the film. I will not support disney, if they'll do this.

it wont be the same.
he makes th movie! lol

Who says that the next movie would happen before the ten years are up? I bet that they work Will and Liz in for a final adventure with Captain Jack Sparrow.

Having Will as captain of the Dutchman and Liz as Pirate King would make just about any story interesting, don't you think? 😄

sorry, but there won't be a POTC 4 without Johnny....so this topic is really useless...cus the writers, directors, everyone know that the Pirate movies would not stand a chance without jack Sparrow...because he is Pirates of the Caribbean.....no way would they make a movie about will and liz and their son....boring...

the only reason they went beyond the original pirate movie was because of johnny depp....end of discussion, really.

so that's it then. WITHOUT JACK = NO PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN ... obsession. like i said, POTC would just be 'just another pirate movie'.

I agreee completely with Jaeh, I mean you simply CANNOT have a POTC WITHOUT CAPTAIN JACK SPARROW!!! SAVVY?

Do not fret, johnny said he would do Captain Jack as long as they would have him and that he loves playing that role!

yea...he has said this:

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/entertainment/2007-05/11/content_870333.htm

and he has always said that. he will be in it if they make it.