Most Influential Rock Artists Ever?

Started by jaden1018 pages
Originally posted by big gay kirk
Take That.... probably the most influential boy band of the nineties... most of the other boy bands of that era and today took their lead from take that... and still do....they were also a great influence on bands like McFly who attempted to change the formula towards a more rock oriented sound, and even more importantly they inspired rock bands such as Travis, Oasis, Franz Ferdinand, White Stripes et al to start making music in order to stop the charts being filled with boy band dross... plus kudos to TT for managing to change with the times, slap Robbie Williams and semi-reinvent themselves as a pop band for today....

new kids on the block...need i say more?

Please justify your inclusion of Mozart in the category of

Most Influential Rock Artists Ever?

Dr. Dre and Timbaland

It seems the influence of the Beatles are hitting hip-hop first Wu Tang used the melody While My Guitar Gently Weeps. Now Ja Rule is using the melody of Eleanor Rigby in one of his tunes on his latest album.

That doesn't count as influence.

Yes taking someone melodies is influence. Or basically it's stealing.

The Beatles were amongst the first, but they were not the first and their influence on the genre is minimal. Pink Floyd was up and making progressive psychedelic music well before The Beatles put anything of the sort on record.

Nellinator that was your words. The Beatles were making progressive psychedelic records on Revolver. Songs like Tomorrow Never Knows, Love You To and She Said She Said with it quirky time signatures were recorded when Pink Floyd were still not a recording group and really goes far above the Yardbirds and Byrds debatable psychedelic records Shapes of Things and Eight Miles High. John Cale said She Said She Said was a big influence on him. Don't minimize Revolver influence on the Byrds Younger Than Yesterday and Revolver and Strawberry Fields Forever influence on Pink Floyd.

Another influential song was Eleanor Rigby how many rock groups were doing tunes with classical influence, no rock instruments with just vocals and strings. Rain was also innovative with it's backward vocal fade out and upfront unusual drum and bass pattern. What is the connection these songs were recorded in 1966 before the Doors and 13th Floor Elevator first records were out. You really are underestimating the Beatles originality and influence on both psychedelic and progressive rock. The Beatles were already flirting with psychedelic music on The Word listen to the trippy harmonium fills and the psychedelic pop of Nowhere Man in 1965.

When mentioning psychedelic, one cannot forget the grateful dead.

But whatever....this beatles love fest gets old. Yes they were innovative, but people have done it better since. And I do like the Beatles, not taking anything away from them at all.

the fact of the matter is that none of us are entitled to say what bands influenced what bands...only they themselves can say and very few of them do...an example would be when i watched a metallica interview and lars said that they were being influenced heavily, post black album, by Oasis...would anyone know that if they hadn't said it?....doubtful

i think that producers probably had a bigger influence as they were the ones with the access to the new technologies and ways in which bands were utilising them...and as such were probably spreading the word

Why did I somehow know that this was up the page due to some kind of Beatlemania?

-AC

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
Why did I somehow know that this was up the page due to some kind of Beatlemania?

-AC

Some people just can't let go...