movie silver surfer vs movie superman

Started by Deathstroke6 pages
Originally posted by Superboy Prime
My main beef with Returns is the extended ending sequence with the Superman in a coma stuff...not to mention I hated that kid.

The kid was definitely the worst part for me. They should've gotten rid of the kid and either made the movie 20 minutes shorter or had 20 more minutes of action.

Originally posted by quanchi112
good one comedian.

I'm glad you enjoyed it, but in my opinion it's the truth.

Originally posted by quanchi112
superman had to trick them outta thier powers to beat them. surfer beats movie supes.

And Surfer got taken out even easier...and Doom with SS powers got taken out by a bootleg superskrull.

Movie Surfer would be nothing more than a minor annoyance.

Originally posted by Deathstroke
Superman Returns had its problems, but it was still better than FF2.

✅ And this is coming from someone who hates SR with a passion.

i think movie SS would atomize movie superman.... not to say movie superman wasnt faster and stronger, its just i dont think physical force would work on him

Atomize Superman my ass.

Physical force worked perfectly in order to separate Doom from the surfboard.

And that's all Superman would have to do. Without the surfboard, Norrin was nothing more than a sniveling little douche bag.

My God people, movie Surfer in comparison to Reeve's Superman was nothing. Superman was IMMENSELY faster and stronger. All he needs to do is fly into him faster than light (and anybody who said Norrin flew faster than light in the movie... that's bullshit. Johnny was able to catch up to him during their encounter.) and knock the crap outta him.

Plus, as Avy pointed out earlier, Johnny with the F4's powers straight up raped Doom with the PC. And hell, he only used his own, Reed's, and Ben's powers offensively against him.

crylaugh @ anybody saying movie Norrin is >>>> movie Superman. He didn't display anything to suggest so. If you hop off of the Surfer's sack for a second, you'd be able to see that.

Separating Surfer from the board by physical force wouldn't stop Surfer. Reed's device is what scrambled the connection between Surfer and his board and thus the powers. Notice near the end, Surfer called to board to his side.

Don't get me wrong. Superman beats Surfer with ease but I just felt like being a douche and pointing that out.

Originally posted by Validus
Separating Surfer from the board by physical force wouldn't stop Surfer. Reed's device is what scrambled the connection between Surfer and his board and thus the powers. Notice near the end, Surfer called to board to his side.

Don't get me wrong. Superman beats Surfer with ease but I just felt like being a douche and pointing that out.

I'm talking about when the Super Skrull wannabe knocked Doom off the surfboard.

But yes, Reed's device was used in order to separate him from the board. However, at that point during the movie, they never tried to use physical force in order to separate him from the board. Unless of course you count those missiles they used against him.

However, what do you think Supes would do after he got Norrin off the board? Wait for him to summon it, while Clark plays pattycake quietly with himself off in the distance? **** no. He caves in Norrin's shiny dome piece.

Also, you're implying that the device Reed made shut off his powers. He still was able to call the surfboard to his side at the end anyways. The reason he didn't before hand was because he was knocked out by Doom's electricity, and they confiscated the board. Notice, Doom had to take the board out of the nullifying field in order to take control of it. So, essentially, Reed's device only equates to what Johnny did, and what Superman's gonna do to Norrin. 🙂

Reed's device didn't shut off his powers. It just scrambled his connection to them. At that point, with the machine still turned on, he couldn't even physically grab his board

Super Skrull Johnny was able to knock Doom off the board but that was only after the device Doom had on his wrist to control the board was destroyed. If it wasn't he could have regained control.

Point is, Surfer doesn't need to be standing on his board to exert control and it's not implied he needs to be on it to use his powers either. After he destroys Cloudlactus, he's floating in space with his silver sheen intact.

Originally posted by Validus
Reed's device didn't shut off his powers. It just scrambled his connection to them. At that point, with the machine still turned on, he couldn't even physically grab his board

Super Skrull Johnny was able to knock Doom off the board but that was only after the device Doom had on his wrist to control the board was destroyed. If it wasn't he could have regained control.

Point is, Surfer doesn't need to be standing on his board to exert control and it's not implied he needs to be on it to use his powers either. After he destroys Cloudlactus, he's floating in space with his silver sheen intact.

Cellophane "S" ftw.

Originally posted by Validus
Reed's device didn't shut off his powers. It just scrambled his connection to them. At that point, with the machine still turned on, he couldn't even physically grab his board

Super Skrull Johnny was able to knock Doom off the board but that was only after the device Doom had on his wrist to control the board was destroyed.

You threw me off when you said "and thus, the powers." As in, his powers were all f*cked up.

Regardless, Ben's punches were still able to "clobber" Doom on the surf board. What the f*ck do you think Superman's punches would do to him considering he's a SHIT load stronger than Ben (Thing couldn't even pull a firetruck... 😂 @ Ben) and a SHIT load faster than the Human Torch and Surfer.

Norrin wouldn't be able to do anything. The most impressive thing he displayed was destroying Galactus, but he had to channel the power for awhile leaving himself vulnerable. Supes isn't going to give him that opportunity. Even then, in terms of power, it doesn't really compare to some of the shit Reeve's Superman pulled. I mean... rewinding time? 🤨

Super cellophane ftw.

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
Cellophane "S" ftw.

Originally posted by batdude123
You threw me off when you said "and thus, the powers." As in, his powers were all f*cked up.

Regardless, Ben's punches were still able to "clobber" Doom on the surf board. What the f*ck do you think Superman's punches would do to him considering he's a SHIT load stronger than Ben (Thing couldn't even pull a firetruck... 😂 @ Ben) and a SHIT load faster than the Human Torch and Surfer.

Norrin wouldn't be able to do anything. The most impressive thing he displayed was destroying Galactus, but he had to channel the power for awhile leaving himself vulnerable. Supes isn't going to give him that opportunity. Even then, in terms of power, it doesn't really compare to some of the shit Reeve's Superman pulled. I mean... rewinding time? 🤨

Super cellophane ftw.

😂

Thing's strength was better in the 2nd movie. He did lift that ferris wheel by himself.

Still, like I said before, Superman wins easy. I just wanted to point that out.

Originally posted by Validus
Thing's strength was better in the 2nd movie. He did lift that ferris wheel by himself.

That's true. Their powers did seem enhanced compared to the first movie. hmm

Still, moving the moon with ease and flying a kryptonite island at escape velocity>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>lifting a ferris wheel with extreme difficulty.

Superman probably wins. Both movies were shitty.

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Superman probably wins. Both movies were shitty.

Superman Returns was meh.

F4 2 was meh.

Superman and Superman 2 were great though.

I honestly think F4 2 was better. Superman Returns was just...wow.

Im pretty sure since anything the board draws near, energy is drained from, granted supes will punch surfer miles away but it wont do anything, second he gets close again he will be drained a lil more... and so on and so on... i mean just flying over a lake in less than a second froze it solid (if u didnt know kids... heat is energy... ergo he took all the energy out of it). that remains true for non organics at least.... he alters anything organic he touchs or shoots

Originally posted by batdude123
Superman Returns was meh.

F4 2 was meh.

Superman and Superman 2 were great though.

Surfer would have kneeled b4 ZOD on planet Houston. 😄

Mind erasing superkiss ftw.

Originally posted by Validus
I honestly think F4 2 was better. Superman Returns was just...wow.

Perhaps. I actually enjoyed F4 2 which was more than I expected based on the first one.

Originally posted by Hannibal-Lector
Im pretty sure since anything the board draws near, energy is drained from, granted supes will punch surfer miles away but it wont do anything, second he gets close again he will be drained a lil more... and so on and so on... i mean just flying over a lake in less than a second froze it solid (if u didnt know kids... heat is energy... ergo he took all the energy out of it). that remains true for non organics at least.... he alters anything organic he touchs or shoots

Nothing he did compared to movie Superman was impressive in the least bit. You think solidifying a few bodies of water is what it takes in order to beat Earth spinning Superman? crylaugh

Surfer goes down easily.