Charlie Bone vs Harry Potter?

Has anyone read any of the Charlie Bone books? I looked at the description of book 1 in the series and it sounded like kind of a rip off of the Harry Potter books.

I'm just wondering if anybody has read them and if someone has, are they actually any good...how much different are they from the Potter books (because I seriously doubt they could even be half as good as the Potter books).

Never heard of them....or maybe I have hmm

Yeah I hadn't either until I saw them near Harry Potter books in Borders and Barnes & Noble. I just wonder if they're any good...but they sound like a complete rip off of the Potter books.

Hmm...If I remember to, I'll check them out hmm

I read the 3rd book(couldn't really understand the book since I didn't read from the starting) and no,Its not a rip-off.I bought it from Scholastic and the ad was"Do you like Harry Potter books?If you do then you might love Charlie Bone!".Its different though and not at all like Hp.

Are they good though??

I dont know.I never really understood it very well.I guess its okay but not that good.

o0o0o0o

yupz

I've read them all. Good series, aimed at younger readers than Harry Potter, but still good.

Originally posted by [Walkah]
I've read them all. Good series, aimed at younger readers than Harry Potter, but still good.

Originally posted by The Phantom
How young? Harry Potter is meant for a young audience too.

Well, Jenny Nimmo writes in a way that is easier for younger audiences to understand. I mean, they'll get more than just the main idea. If you read the books I think you might understand my meaning more.

Charlie Bone is good im on the 4th book.and its not a complete rip off.
tell me how many people do you in harry potter who have mutant powers.And if you like The X-Men you will love charlie bone.Charlie bone is a great descandant of the Red King.The Red King's desandants have 1 of his pwoers like Tancred.He has storm power's.Its very good though.

D-D-Did you j-just say STORM'S POWER!!!!!!!!

GOTTA FIND THESE BOOKS!

tripp

anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

mmm Who bumped this thread.

Don't hate. Book sounds good and Harry Potter is over.

anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

Originally posted by InnerRise
D-D-Did you j-just say STORM'S POWER!!!!!!!!

GOTTA FIND THESE BOOKS!

tripp

anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

charlie brown vs harry potter ??!! wtf

oooh charlie bone.

is it one of those crappy , kids or teens with powers to save the world thing ? cause im sick of seeing that stuff EVERYWHERE