Alan Moore vs Frank Miller

Started by Entity1 pagesPoll

Poll

Alan Moore or Frank Miller?

3 total votes

Entity Illuminati Founder

Alan Moore vs Frank Miller

These are probably my 2 all time favorite writers ever. Which do you think is the better writer over all?
Is there anyone you think is better than both of them and do you have any problems with either of their writing personally?

TricksterPriest Renegade Timelord

Alan Moore by a mile. Miller hasn't done anything on par with V for Vendetta or Watchmen. 😎

Entity Illuminati Founder

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Alan Moore by a mile. Miller hasn't done anything on par with V for Vendetta or Watchmen. 😎
Maybe not on par with Watchmen but The Return of the Dark Knight and Sin City are pretty damn awesome! At least close to tied with V! IMO

nvrbeenwthagirl Restricted

The Dark Knight

TricksterPriest Renegade Timelord
Originally posted by Entity
Maybe not on par with Watchmen but The Return of the Dark Knight and Sin City are pretty damn awesome! At least close to tied with V! IMO

Problem is, things like All Star Batman bring his average wayyyyyyyy down. 😆

guy222 With my gal

Re: Alan Moore vs Frank Miller

Originally posted by Entity
These are probably my 2 all time favorite writers ever. Which do you think is the better writer over all?
Is there anyone you think is better than both of them and do you have any problems with either of their writing personally?

Miller

norrinradd43 Sentinel of the Spaceways

Kevin Smith has the potential to be up there, he needs to do more though, guardian devil was the shizznit

Entity Illuminati Founder

Originally posted by norrinradd43
Kevin Smith has the potential to be up there, he needs to do more though, guardian devil was the shizznit
I ****ing love everything Kevin Smith touches almost but I never really saw him as the same league as Moore and Miller.

All his movies ROCK thou.
Save Jersey Girl. 😮