Imagine the Butchering for DH
This books has some wicked sweet scenes so far if I do say so myself. But what I worry is they will butcher the hell out of this for the movie. the locket scene could be unexistent! OH FREAKIN NO!
your thoughts 😕
ALTHOUGH. i must say the relationships of the characters are more possible to be well translated though
It's going to be hard not to "butcher it", as some say. The film can't pretend it's just a simple adaptation (ala the first two Potter films); it needs to move with pace and with drama. The charm of the previous books usually takes place in the form of the Hogwarts life, the wonders of magic et cetera et cetera. This book does not have that. Expect lots of montage sequences.
Magic in this book is not so much a helpful tool but something that could quite easily stab you in the back, nearly every scene (now the whimsical oddities of the school are removed) is important to the overall plot.
This book will be murdered, but I think it will be a great film.
Well they better not butcher Ron's shining moments or I swear -- I will burn Leavesden Studios down to the ground!!
Buh. I don't even want to THINK about it yet.
I was pondering last night if Andromeda's appearance is important enough to warrant her appearing in the movie. I doubt it 🙁
And I disagree hugely on the relationships of the characters being well-translated, as all through the movies it's been made out to seem that it's Harry and Hermione that will get together.
Originally posted by Lana
And I disagree hugely on the relationships of the characters being well-translated, as all through the movies it's been made out to seem that it's Harry and Hermione that will get together.
Ever since Alfonso Cauron took the reigns with the third, it's been pretty explicit that Ron and Hermione are always the first to comfort each other. JK Rowling said Cauron had gone in places she was going with the books unawares, pretty sure she means that.
Harry and Hermione is a relationship that people constantly question in the books too, don't forget. So it's not a real surprise that it translates like that on-screen.
Some people may disagree with me, but I think Harry and Hermione have a special relationship that seems to transcend simple friendship. Harry says he loves her like a sister and she feels the same way, but in a way it goes even beyond that.
No, I'm not talking about romance, but they seem to have a closeness, both in the way they behave around each other and their physicality that is easily misinterperated as romance. This is especially true in DH, when Ron is gone and Harry has those moments with Hermione that speaks volumes of their relationship together, so it will be interesting how they will handle that on-screen.
Originally posted by Lana
Buh. I don't even want to THINK about it yet.I was pondering last night if Andromeda's appearance is important enough to warrant her appearing in the movie. I doubt it 🙁
And I disagree hugely on the relationships of the characters being well-translated, as all through the movies it's been made out to seem that it's Harry and Hermione that will get together.
Yeah they do with having hermione hugging harry every time he even gets a paper cut 😬 but I still think it is brother and sister chemistray. I agree with surreal 44. the relationship between them is needed to build up ron's jelousy he'd eventually have.
Originally posted by ~LunaLoveG~More of a mother-son relationship.
Yeah they do with having hermione hugging harry every time he even gets a paper cut 😬 but I still think it is brother and sister chemistray. I agree with surreal 44. the relationship between them is needed to build up ron's jelousy he'd eventually have.
Oh no...Harry and Hermione do not have a mother/son relationship. 😛 That's saved for Mrs. Weasley/Harry. Hermione's role plays into that slightly, but her relationship is not mother/son.
There's a reason people are jealous of the relationship Harry and Hermione have, and it's not because they act like mother and son, or even brother and sister. It's more complex than that. They aren't lovers or romantic, obviously (we've known that since book 4), but there is more touching between them than you see in a typical brother/sister relationship.
There's no real word for it that I can think of at the moment, but I would never put it as mother/son.
But back to the original topic (if we want to discuss Harry and Hermione's non-romantic relationship, should we start a new thread?), DH is going to mutilated, but hopefully not beyond recognition.
I see them squishing quite a few scenes together in order for the whole story to get across, but even if they cut out a whole lot of the book, I still see this being a 3 hour movie.
Scenes I think will get cut are things with Tonks and Lupin, most of Voldemort's search for that one particular item he's so keen to find, and I think Kreacher's scenes will be changed drastically in the film.
Originally posted by Joy2dWorld
Well they better not butcher Ron's shining moments or I swear -- I will burn Leavesden Studios down to the ground!!
agreed ✅