The Cruciatus Curse: Tell me why you believe it is unforgivable.

In general, I consider rabid Harry Potter fans to be something less than human, relatively unworthy of my time.

However, you may be able to redeem yourselves by answering this question:

"Why is the Cruciatus curse unforgivable?"

I'll give you a hint: there are two reasons, and only one of them is specifically mentioned.

Any time you put someone in pain intentionally is quite unforgivable in my eyes.

I guess those doctors who worked pre-anesthesia were all going straight to hell, then.

Because it's torture. Think whatever us Muggles have for torture, take that and mutiply it five times over. They have magic to do it, we don't.

Do you think torture is a forgivable thing?

You have only given the obvious reason. I told you that there were two.

Then again, what was I to expect from H.P. fanatics...?

Originally posted by FeceMan
You have only given the obvious reason. I told you that there were two.

Then again, what was I to expect from H.P. fanatics...?

Wow, you are rude and stupid, how does this combination help you outside the forums? Been violently attacked lately? No? Shame 🙁

Originally posted by FeceMan
Then again, what was I to expect from H.P. fanatics...?

hmm...how about a wand up your a$$.

honestly. if you think it is such a waste of time why bother. Wiki it or something. don't get an excuse to push around HP fanatics of which we are proud to be

Originally posted by FeceMan
You have only given the obvious reason. I told you that there were two.

Then again, what was I to expect from H.P. fanatics...?

Rather than being offensive, why don't you enlighten us, oh brilliant one?

Originally posted by FeceMan
In general, I consider rabid Harry Potter fans to be something less than human, relatively unworthy of my time.

However, you may be able to redeem yourselves by answering this question:

"Why is the Cruciatus curse unforgivable?"

I'll give you a hint: there are two reasons, and only one of them is specifically mentioned.

Because if you were closer to me I would have used it on you. And only then you would realize whow stupid you are to come here and bark so stupidly. You prat

I'm giving you a hint: Do this again and I will report you!

You know the reason most people troll on Harry Potter fans is because they claim to be able to do magic on them? 😬

Statement: The responses elicited are those as expected from Harry Potter fans--both unintelligent and demonstrating the inability to see beyond the figurative ends of their own noses.

Statement: There are two components to the Cruciatus curse: the incantation itself and the will of the caster.

Evidence: In the battle of the Department of Mysteries, Harry attempts to use the Cruciatus curse on Bellatrix Lestrange. It is ineffective, and she taunts him saying, "You've got to mean them, Potter! Righteous anger won't hurt me for long."

She also explains that the Cruciatus curse is only effective when the caster is causing pain for the (perverse) enjoyment of causing another to be in pain.

Corollary: For the Cruciatus curse to work, it indicates a mentality in the caster: sadism.

Conclusion: The Cruciatus curse is unforgivable not only because it is a curse designed specifically to torture, but the curse's effectiveness is based upon the mindset of the caster that, when effective, indicates that the caster is dangerous to everyone around him or her.

Originally posted by FeceMan
Statement: The responses elicited are those as expected from Harry Potter fans--both unintelligent and demonstrating the inability to see beyond the figurative ends of their own noses.

Statement: There are two components to the Cruciatus curse: the incantation itself and the will of the caster.

Evidence: In the battle of the Department of Mysteries, Harry attempts to use the Cruciatus curse on Bellatrix Lestrange. It is ineffective, and she taunts him saying, "You've got to mean them, Potter! Righteous anger won't hurt me for long."

She also explains that the Cruciatus curse is only effective when the caster is causing pain for the (perverse) enjoyment of causing another to be in pain.

Corollary: For the Cruciatus curse to work, it indicates a mentality in the caster: sadism.

Conclusion: The Cruciatus curse is unforgivable not only because it is a curse designed specifically to torture, but the curse's effectiveness is based upon the mindset of the caster that, when effective, indicates that the caster is dangerous to everyone around him or her.

Ok.

Originally posted by FeceMan
Statement: The responses elicited are those as expected from Harry Potter fans--both unintelligent and demonstrating the inability to see beyond the figurative ends of their own noses.

Statement: There are two components to the Cruciatus curse: the incantation itself and the will of the caster.

Evidence: In the battle of the Department of Mysteries, Harry attempts to use the Cruciatus curse on Bellatrix Lestrange. It is ineffective, and she taunts him saying, "You've got to mean them, Potter! Righteous anger won't hurt me for long."

She also explains that the Cruciatus curse is only effective when the caster is causing pain for the (perverse) enjoyment of causing another to be in pain.

Corollary: For the Cruciatus curse to work, it indicates a mentality in the caster: sadism.

Conclusion: The Cruciatus curse is unforgivable not only because it is a curse designed specifically to torture, but the curse's effectiveness is based upon the mindset of the caster that, when effective, indicates that the caster is dangerous to everyone around him or her.

*Claps*

If anything, it sounds like it is you who has put too much time into thinking about Harry Potter.

Originally posted by FeceMan
Statement: The responses elicited are those as expected from Harry Potter fans--both unintelligent and demonstrating the inability to see beyond the figurative ends of their own noses.

Statement: There are two components to the Cruciatus curse: the incantation itself and the will of the caster.

Evidence: In the battle of the Department of Mysteries, Harry attempts to use the Cruciatus curse on Bellatrix Lestrange. It is ineffective, and she taunts him saying, "You've got to mean them, Potter! Righteous anger won't hurt me for long."

She also explains that the Cruciatus curse is only effective when the caster is causing pain for the (perverse) enjoyment of causing another to be in pain.

Corollary: For the Cruciatus curse to work, it indicates a mentality in the caster: sadism.

Conclusion: The Cruciatus curse is unforgivable not only because it is a curse designed specifically to torture, but the curse's effectiveness is based upon the mindset of the caster that, when effective, indicates that the caster is dangerous to everyone around him or her.

Well written, no doubt spot on, blah blah blah.

I am, however, offended by the fact that you decided to label every HP fan as 'unintelligent' and unable to 'see beyond... their own noses'. I don't think it likely that you'll care whether I'm offended or not, I just thought I'd throw it out there. I'm offended. I love Harry Potter, I don't think I'm stupid or short-sighted and I am offended 🙂

Originally posted by FeceMan
Statement: The responses elicited are those as expected from Harry Potter fans--both unintelligent and demonstrating the inability to see beyond the figurative ends of their own noses.

Statement: There are two components to the Cruciatus curse: the incantation itself and the will of the caster.

Evidence: In the battle of the Department of Mysteries, Harry attempts to use the Cruciatus curse on Bellatrix Lestrange. It is ineffective, and she taunts him saying, "You've got to mean them, Potter! Righteous anger won't hurt me for long."

She also explains that the Cruciatus curse is only effective when the caster is causing pain for the (perverse) enjoyment of causing another to be in pain.

Corollary: For the Cruciatus curse to work, it indicates a mentality in the caster: sadism.

Conclusion: The Cruciatus curse is unforgivable not only because it is a curse designed specifically to torture, but the curse's effectiveness is based upon the mindset of the caster that, when effective, indicates that the caster is dangerous to everyone around him or her.

He's lying ermm

Originally posted by Unicor777
I'm giving you a hint: Do this again and I will report you!

xDDD no1 likes a snitch

Why make a thread asking why it's unforgivable when you know why it's unforgivable? 😕

I'm unintelligent but a lot of HP fans are really clever and work out all the inner meanings to stuff.

For your information I did know both reasons the cruciatus curse is unforgivable! And I'm really stupid! So it doesn't make you clever knowing if people like me can work it out!

Originally posted by steverules
Why make a thread asking why it's unforgivable when you know why it's unforgivable? 😕

Because the Creator of the thread gets to seem more intelligent by calling others stupid and boring us with a piece of information I couldn't care less about but makes the guy who insults everyone feel like a big clever boy ✅