Hitomi vs Sakura Kasugano

Originally posted by Cale_Daziel
So, lets get this right, the ability to impress Ryu + potential upside >>> Hitomi's Sucess + Experience?

Actually I would say Sakura has more experience than Hitomi. Hitomi has only been in 2 tournaments, ya know? Sakura on the other hand started street fighting and eventually got involved in Alpha 3's messed up plot. Appearance wise they are dead even with Sakura appearing in Alpha 2 and 3; Hitomi appearing in DOA3 and DOA4. And to be honest I doubt Hitomi did anything worthy in DOA4 given how she was pretty much on crack in the cut-scenes and ending.

Originally posted by Cale_Daziel

Hitomi fought against Hayate, and although she lost, I'd say Hayate is about par with Bison. By reading the wikipedia post on Sakura, it sounds like she was beaten soundly and easily, where as Hitomi was atleast competitive against Hayate. Based on that alone, you'd almost say that Hitomi's faced off against opponents equal to that of what Sakura's faced and had more success, so therefore Hitomi gets the nod based on the competition, and sucess she's faced.

You think Hayate is on par with Bison...WOW.

Originally posted by Cale_Daziel

Ryu is a bit better than Ken, so Sakura's sparring with Ken means very little if she's training with Ryu. Hitomi trained with Ein (Hayate) for a stint, plus has been a black belt for many years and would have a great deal more experience, even including Sakura's stint with Ryu. You can't suggest that Ken/Ryu is that much better than Hayate, so the two girls have both sparred with great fighters.

What? Ryu may be better than Ken but that does not take away from sparring with Ken because Ken is no pushover either. Not to mention she's fighting them with an emulated style. For this matchup she WILL know how to perform the actual moves, and that will secure the win for Sakura. Hayate H2H should not be mentioned in the same sentence as Ryu & Ken, but I just did that. I hate myself now.

[QUOTE=9327168]Originally posted by Cale_Daziel
[B]
So keeping in mind that the two have similar backgrounds and only Hitomi has proven results, I'd say Hitomi wins. It's great that Sakura has upside, but whether or not it materializes is something completely different. Hitomi, who would be 21 according to the storyline, would only have improved as well, not to mention that at 18 she finished 3rd in the DOA3 tournament.

Against fighers we don't know. The only person we know she beat is Jann Lee, and he does not come close to the level of competition Sakura faced in Alpha games.

Originally posted by Cale_Daziel

Who knows what Hitomi might have accomplished in that three year period, but it's likely that she'll have improved as well since she too has massive upside, and I'd say more than Sakura since... well, you know, Hitomi has actually accomplished something.

In fact, I can't even see why this match would be close...

duriroll

😕

Hitomi is two years older and has been a black-belt for quiet a while and practising Karate even longer. Sakura, from the film I watched, decided when she was 15-16 to begin getting into Karate. Hitomi has more experience, and sucess, regardless of being in the same amount of video game apperances. Besides, atleast Hitomi's done something to merit having the label 'potenial upside' attached to her, unlike Sakura, who really hasn't done a whole lot of... well... anything.

I dislike Hayate, but I know he's tough. I don't know a lot about Bison. The point was they can both fight powerful opponents and that they have practised with foes who are of great strength.

Speaking of Sakura's awesome record anyway, all she's done is lose to Karin twice, fought Honda (don't know who won), and got beaten by Bison... that's an awesome record right there, huh?

* I got that information from wikipedia, don't know how accurate it is, but I'll roll with it.

Hitomi's finished 3rd, and while we only know she beat Jann Lee, you have to assume she beat more than just him to rank so high. Besides, at least we can say Hitomi has for sure won something. I'd say that Karin, who defeated Sakura twice, isn't nearly as good as some of the DOA competitors Hitomi would have encountered. I'd also throw Honda into that category as well.

So other than Bison, who handily defeated Sakura, she really hasn't had much in terms of difficult competition. Atleast Hitomi has won atleast one fight, and likely several others. We also know Hitomi beat Lei fang in DOA4 as expressed in her ending (the cabbage tie in), so that's two wins for Hitomi, and Sakura is seemingly still with a goose egg.

Again, Hitomi's more experienced and had sucess. Sakura would still be inexperienced in comparison to Hitomi, who's been training much longer and actually won matches. I don't see Sakura beating Hitomi until she start winning... anything... maybe a fight would be a good starting place.

I'm going to have to give it to Hitomi, sure, Sakura has chi control and knows some Ansatsuken, but it when you think about it, it all counts up to experience, doesn't it?

Hitomi has competed in two of the DOA tournaments, and in one of them she had gained third place which that alone is a feat in itself.

Sakura, has only fought college frat boys according to her storyline, and to some extent, Karin Kanzuki. So does she have the experience which Hitomi does? No, not at all. And sure, Sakura fought Ryu-- but he had to pull his punches and hold back on her. So did she really learn anything then? Not necessarily.

However, Sakura does have a never say die attitude with her, which Hitomi also does posses.

But Hitomi is a hard hitter, one good hit... Sakura KOed.

Hitomi can't throw hadou-kens! She loses!

Skill wise Bison gets beat by Hayate. Its just Bison Phyoco power that gives him the win

Phyoco power? ermm

Sakura...

Originally posted by Warakia
I'm going to have to give it to Hitomi, sure, Sakura has chi control and knows some Ansatsuken, but it when you think about it, it all counts up to experience, doesn't it?

Hitomi has competed in two of the DOA tournaments, and in one of them she had gained third place which that alone is a feat in itself.

Sakura, has only fought college frat boys according to her storyline, and to some extent, Karin Kanzuki. So does she have the experience which Hitomi does? No, not at all. And sure, Sakura fought Ryu-- but he had to pull his punches and hold back on her. So did she really learn anything then? Not necessarily.

However, Sakura does have a never say die attitude with her, which Hitomi also does posses.

But Hitomi is a hard hitter, one good hit... Sakura KOed.

Agreed

They both are pretty much lacking showings of actual stats.

Though if we were to use outside/fake/noncanon material, you name it, Hitomi wins due to her showings in Dead Fantasy.

Come to think of it, I don't think Sakura has anything besides beating Dan's ass (which anyone can do).