Mixed Genre & Comic Tier Reference Guide

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Illa, you are a genius. 😄 This should probably be in the comic book section though. 😛

1 vote for Alucard for high/mid herald and 1 vote for mid meta

Lina Inverse for mid herald (1)

Link for mid meta (1)

Dante for high meta (1)

Anubis & Jehuty for mid herald evillaugh you have no idea how long I've been trying to get those two into the other tier list......

Spike Spiegel for high street (1)

Ranma Saotome for low meta (1)

Ryouga Hibiki for low meta (1)

Happosai for mid/high meta (1)

Rugal Bernstein for high meta/ low herald (1)

Kelthuzad for mid herald (1)

Don't let Arthas on the list. Seriously. He's at least skyfather. Unless it's DK Arthas, in which case, mid/high meta.

Where do we put alternate forms? Or they count under the main character? If the latter, change Rugal to low herald.

Kain from Legacy Of Kain-Herald level mid/high
Kratos-Herald level low

3 votes for Master Chief to mid meta level

2 votes for Samus for high meta

2 votes for Ryu Hayabusa for low meta

1 vote for Gouki to low herald and 1 vote for meta (tier not specified)

1 vote for Mega Man to high-meta or low herald.

1 vote for Sephiroth to mid meta

1 vote for Aizen Sousuke for Low herald and 1 for mid meta

1 vote for Cutie Honey for mid/high meta

Alita from Battle Angel Alita for low meta

Um Megaman is nowhere NEAR low herald/High meta I'd put him at Mid meta TOPS.

Megaman lifted a castle at base. Go figure.

Plus he has many other abilities. Needless to say Megaman stomps Samus Aran without difficulty.

Base Megaman or Fully Equipped Megaman?

When?

Originally posted by illadelph12
Base Megaman or Fully Equipped Megaman?

We're using Megaman from his storyline. In his storyline he gains all the abilities of the bots he battles. Base level would just have a megabuster. Fully equipped, depending on at which point we take him from in his storyline, would have a lot of abilities stored.

X series megaman was even more powerful.

Samus Aran vs Mega Man

I agree that X is high Meta (When fully enhanced) but regular megaman is far below him.

We have got to change some of the tiers. Wave rider is in the middle tier when he clearly is as powerful or more so than most of the top tiers.

You can discuss that over in the original list at the Comic Books Forum Nvr. We're just using that list as benchmarks for the Extended Genre Characters to establish where they'd stand compared to mainstream peers.

I'll agree with Trick's placement of the ranma characters. For the time being at any rate.

Though I'm curious as to the criterium of the placements of characters, is it just ABC ad hoc logic Or are there specific requirements to be placed at a given level?

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Kain from Legacy Of Kain-Herald level mid/high
Kratos-Herald level low

3 votes for Master Chief to mid meta level

2 votes for Samus for high meta

2 votes for Ryu Hayabusa for low meta

1 vote for Gouki to low herald and 1 vote for meta (tier not specified)

1 vote for Mega Man to high-meta or low herald.

1 vote for Sephiroth to mid meta

1 vote for Aizen Sousuke for Low herald and 1 for mid meta

1 vote for Cutie Honey for mid/high meta

Alita from Battle Angel Alita for low meta

Z from tenchi Muyo for high herald level.
here's an example of two of his attacks

before

after

I change my vote on Aizen to high Meta

I actually think Z is probably Transendent.

Originally posted by Akuki
Z from tenchi Muyo for high herald level.
here's an example of two of his attacks

before

after

I change my vote on Aizen to high Meta

Holy...

Z is totaly Trans, if not Skyfather in and of himself.

Originally posted by Creshosk
I'll agree with Trick's placement of the ranma characters. For the time being at any rate.

Though I'm curious as to the criterium of the placements of characters, is it just ABC ad hoc logic Or are there specific requirements to be placed at a given level?

We're placing the characters in tiers comparable to their mainstream comic counterparts. In other words, the criteria is where would their abilities place them when compared to a "mainstream" peer of equal/similar ability, not who they would defeat in a fight.

Originally posted by King Kandy
Z is totaly Trans, if not Skyfather in and of himself.

What are your guys opinions on merged Knives from trigun?
I think he shoudl qualify for high meta or low herald but I'm leaning more towards high meta at the moment.