Rick Deckard- Human or Replicant?

Started by Etrigan1 pagesPoll

Deckard: Replicant or Human?

Rick Deckard- Human or Replicant?

This thread concerns the great question which Blade Runner fans will always be divided by. Is Deckard, the protagonist of Ridley Scott's classic, a Replicant or a human?

Fiirstly I would like to say that I was absolutely sure there would already be a thread about this. But I searched as thoroughly as possible and found nothing. If there is already a topic on this then I apologize. I just thought this would be a good topic to discuss and see opinions.

Ridley Scott has already said himself that Rick Deckard was a Replicant.

Phillip K Dick intended Deckard to be a human. Ridley Scott siad he intended him to be a replicant years after he and Harrison Ford agreed he was a human. Just pick whatever you want in all fairness!

Regardless of whether he was a human or replicant, Blade Runner was one of the greatest movies of all time.

Okay, here's what i've found regarding this topic:

• Rick Deckard Replicant or Not?
o Pros:
[list] The ‘unicorn dream’ tells us he has implanted memories
His eyes glow orange when he tells Rachael that he wouldn’t come after her
Roy Batty knows Deckard’s name
Deckard has a thing for photos like the other Replicants
Bryant tells him “If you’re not a cop you’re little people.”
Gaff could be the real Blade Runner, always seeming one step behind
Ridley Scott claims Deckard is a Replicant[/list]
o Cons:
[list] The unaccounted for ‘sixth Replicant’ Bryant mentions is merely a script gaffe
The original cut gives Deckard a back-story, including an ex wife
The contrast between Deckard’s soul-less humanity and Batty’s poetic inhumanity would no longer work
The unicorn may be Rachael’s memory (Deckard has seen her files) and Gaff leaves the origami for her
Why would a “Replicant Cop” be so bitter about his job?
Harrison Ford claims Deckard is not a Replicant [/list]

My view is that i think he is, but i'd rather him not be.

That being said, as im sure youve heard, they're releasing a final cut, and i wonder if there will be any other added scenes/implications toward this subject, since there were huge differences between the '82 and '92 releases

news story here: nytimes.com/2007/09/30/movies/30kapl.html?8dpc=&_r=1&adxnnl=1&oref=slogin&adxnnlx=1191866505-txoXZKDX+ozGNjfmuawb5A

and to add to my last post, there's a whole thread about this going on at the main site if anyone is interested: messageboards.bladerunnerthemovie.com/showthread.php?t=5

Any memories he thinks he has, of his wife & childhood, could all be implanted. And, he doesn't answer Rachel's question about whether he's ever taken a Voight-Kampff test himself. But, I wonder why the police would go through such trouble of using a 'fresh' replicant with implanted memories to do their bidding, except to make sure he does the dirty work of investigating (that makes sense.) If he dies, then it's no loss.