class 100 super brawl..

Originally posted by carver9
Now that was a good post but you fail to realize the times that hulk has withstood 100+ tons punches, shrugging them off. I have seen an angry hulk walk through some of the most strongest punches on the planet. Precrisis superman punched hulk and stated that it was one of his strongest punches and hulk shrugged it off like he didnt feel it ( I know its a cross over but it happened).

The only way again for me to see hulk losing this battle would be by them ganging up on him and I still dont see that as a win since hercules, iron man, vision, wonderman, she hulk doc sampson, war machine, carol danvers, all tried this ganging up on him and they almost got owned and killed until hulk reverted back to bruce banner.

Hulk gets a large majority due to rage and powerset.

I do know one thing, superman isnt winning this fight since he dont have any kind of fighting experience. He is the weakest of the fighters (not strength but skills.) I have seen lex luthor own superman in a one on one slugfest (when superman lost his powers). I can see any of these combatant beating the solar energy out of superman killing him. Superman capabilities falls in his power and speed, he wouldnt know how to accomidate without it.

I think either thor or wonderwoman would be a small problem for the hulk since they are the best fighters on the field.

I see where you are coming from. However, even if Hulk does shrug off punches...he can't shrug off being picked up and literally thrown off the battlefield. Anyone can come up behind him...pick him up...and just toss him before Hulk even knows what's going on.

I know Hulk is durable...but, he can be cut...heck, even Wolverine has cut him...and in my opinion...Wolverine wouldn't be able to cut Supes'. Wolvie couldn't get past Superman's bio-aura. Hulk may have shrugged off blunt force punches in the past...but, I don't think Hulk can just keep shrugging off Supes' strongest punches. Superman killed Doomsday physically...through punches...and Doomsday's durability is much higher than the Hulk's. Hulk has been knocked out by beings less powerful than the combatants in this thread on occasion....Doc Samson for one.

I'm not saying Hulk can't win this match...he most certainly can...but, there is no way he can win it every time...not with this many combatants on the field. At any time, someone can either punch him or throw him off the battefield.

i agree
hulk is the major player here, but he could lose just as easily as win, if you know what i mean

actually Hulk would keep shrugging off Superman's strongest punches, in fact it would become ridiculously ineffective against Hulk quite quickly.

if anyone grabs Hulk, it's guaranteed that they would be crushed in the process of "bfring" him. if it's a group job, all he needs to do is hold onto one or two of the players - which is perfectly reasonable - and the whole attempt falls apart.

Originally posted by KMC_Drifter

Again...it is conceivable to have a different winner each time. It depends on team-ups, being blindsided for BFR...so many variables.

Alas, truer words were never spoken.

..is my point exactly. This fight is too random to call. It makes for interesting debates/scenarios, no doubt.

We can come up with a favorite, (which I don't think is the Hulk by the way), but even so this is not like horse racing, where it's a horse against the track. The favorite in this fight, whoever that is, can be eliminated in mere seconds.

"You're drinking waaaaay to much Strongbow, Newcastle, or Smithwicks if you think Hulk can take this field in physical H2H brawl." ???

Arguing for one over another is understandable. But to imply its ridiculous to favour the Hulk in this contest isn't sensible.
Just look at what he's been doing lately.
( I may be a month or so behind in the issues.)

... I hope he kills Sentry.

WHAT!?! Nobody mentioned Wolverine! 🙄