Top five actors who should have be cast as The Joker.

Honestly? If The Joker is going to be played by anybody, they should be somebody that can bring that insane,funnyman,horrific characteristic to him....if he hadn't already played The Riddler, I'd say Jim Carey. Maybe Robin Williams? Johnny Depp is deffinately a candidate though.

yeah my first choice would have been crispen glover as well.they messed up not casting him.another good choice i think would be jay leno.he has the perfect chin and is a talented celebrity so i think he could pull it off.

I think Jake Busey would have made a good Joker... he has that weird ass smile and those huge teeth... and he's just really creepy.

Johnny Depp
Robin Williams
Crispen Glover
Paul Bettany
Daniel Craig, maybe?

Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
It's been done before....but what the heck? Let's play along...

I'd go with Mark Hamill.

Too old, and he doesn't have the look.

Excellent voice, though.

Originally posted by Toku King
Robin Williams

I can only imagine what that would be like. 😂

Originally posted by batdude123

I can only imagine what that would be like. 😂

Like Heath Ledger no doubt.

gotta think

Sorry, but I find pretty much all of the OP's cast to be very bad choices.

No, I don't want Sean Penn, I don't want the same as Nicholson's. I want some different.

Ledger's Joker looks like a very psychotic person.

i trust Ledger as the Joker, and Michael Caine stating he was breath taken by Ledger only reaffirms this

Johnny Depp

Jack Nicholson

Jim Carrey

Christopher Walken

Jay from Jay and Silent Bob

Originally posted by FistOfThe North
Johnny Depp

Jack Nicholson

Jim Carrey

Christopher Walken

Jay from Jay and Silent Bob

LOL @ Christopher Walken as the Joker.

Originally posted by batdude123
LOL @ Christopher Walken as the Joker.

What? You think he'd be a horrible pick?

I think brokeback mountain proved that heath ledger could play the joker simply because only a demented sadist would go into someone's ass with nothing but spit for lube.