Originally posted by Galan007
Overall,
I think McDuffie is doing a pretty good job in DC -- much more so than in Marvel. 😘
he hasn't reached the heights of crapness he has in marvel thats true, but still, i honestly enjoyed meltzers run alot more... the only real problem with that was the pacing imo... mcduffie just, i dunno... if that issue had been reproduced as an episode of jlu, i'd say it would have been great...
ed benes tho... godly.
Just read the issue. The problem with Mc Duffies work is that its a generic super hero tale. His time on the Fantastic Four was the same 2-3 issues of good vs bad everything is in black and white. And then its just rinse and repeat for every arc. There's no depth it just seems lacking. I'm not saying his work is bad...it's just not anything special. It's solid though I'll give him that much.
My only issue with Mc Duffie is that he doesn't do a very good Batman. That was rather disrepectful what Batman did to Dinah. That just shows a lack of discipline from Batman. Then he makes decisions without consulting with Supes and Diana on a new member.
Hal showing up late for the fight...rather disappointing. Despite all that...it was fun to see the good guys kick ass.
Originally posted by pr1983I think the biggest problem McDuffie has, is the stigma that lingers around him, from past crap he's produced.
he hasn't reached the heights of crapness he has in marvel thats true, but still, i honestly enjoyed meltzers run alot more... the only real problem with that was the pacing imo... mcduffie just, i dunno... if that issue had been reproduced as an episode of jlu, i'd say it would have been great...ed benes tho... godly.
But if you disregard all of that, [it's hard, I know], and only look at what he's done in DC thus far -- it's not too bad overall, imo. [just not very detailed story-wise]..
And Benes = droolio
Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
My only issue with Mc Duffie is that he doesn't do a very good Batman. That was rather disrepectful what Batman did to Dinah. That just shows a lack of discipline from Batman. Then he makes decisions without consulting with Supes and Diana on a new member.Hal showing up late for the fight...rather disappointing. Despite all that...it was fun to see the good guys kick ass.
and they just rolled the f*ck over... considering how much they argued over the lineup originally...
Originally posted by Galan007
I think the biggest problem McDuffie has, is the stigma that lingers around him, from past crap he's produced.But if you disregard all of that, [it's hard, I know], and only look at what he's done in DC thus far -- it's not too bad overall, imo. [just not very detailed story-wise]..
And Benes = droolio
i don't think he writes many of the characters that well though...
if you give him an action story where everyone just spouts one liners he seems to be passable, but ask him to write a deep, interpersonal issue? we're f*cked...
benes is the king... i swear, i read that issue 4 times afterwards just to take in the art...
