All-Star Superman vs Thanos

Started by Priest7 pages

Originally posted by Galan007
One could easily say the same thing in Odin's defense, when he and Thanos fought. 131

True, but in the fight Odin was not going all out like he done in other Battles. He wanted thanos to give up, he wasent trying to kill him

also in the fight the same blast that Koed surfer had no affect on Thanos.

Originally posted by Priest
How bout when Surfer was one shotted by Odin, and thanos took the same shots like nothing.
is that also a testament of surfers versatility?

Thanos has better resistance to magic than Surfer, who has almost none.

Originally posted by Priest
How bout when Surfer was one shotted by Odin, and thanos took the same shots like nothing.
is that also a testament of surfers versatility?

What about when Thanos got attacked by squirrel girl?

Originally posted by batdude123
Especially since Odin grabbed Gungnir to end the fight quickly to no avail. 🙄

Bottom of page:

Originally posted by Galan007
So the same comic where Thanos had to use tech to survive a blast from Galactus (weakened)? 😕

Ok my badd, just read the opening post.😮
Nice handicap on Thanos Sirrus.

Originally posted by Avlon
If I remember correctly, in the battle with red shift..they weren't experiencing the effect of the black hole.

ie: It wasn't natural durability.


That wasn't the only time Surfer's been in a black hole though. He also entered one to retrieve some of the Elders of the Universe from the realm of Magic, and he's used them numerous times to traverse the universe. Galactus himself has flat out said that Surfer is capable of surviving...

Originally posted by Priest
True, but in the fight Odin was not going all out like he done in other Battles. He wanted thanos to give up, he wasent trying to kill him
Then this should be taken into account before the "Thanos stalemated Odin" argument is used.

Originally posted by Avlon
Thanos has better resistance to magic than Surfer, who has almost none.

where is that stated?
so Drax also has no resistance to Magic i guess to since he got one shotted as well.

Originally posted by Priest
Ok my badd, just read the opening post.😮
Nice handicap on Thanos Sirrus.

That's not a handicap.

If Thanos isn't powerful enough to fight without
his tech, then so beit.

Originally posted by Galan007
Then this should be taken into account before the "Thanos stalemated Odin" argument is used.

i agree, its only quan that uses that argument.

Originally posted by Sirius77
That's not a handicap.

If Thanos isn't powerful enough to fight without
his tech, then so beit.


ur taking away standrad abilities and equipment, its a handicap 🙄

Originally posted by batdude123
This:

http://i31.photobucket.com/albums/c379/Doggydogg/SupermanandThorbrawlin3.jpg

Doesn't show them as equivalents.

I recall Thanos stopping Mjolnir with a wave of his hand...

How could Thanos do that again?

All Star Superman shook the world while arm wrestling, I have lots of doubts concerning Thanos winning this battle. Plus he lifted more than a quintillion ton with one arm behind his back.

Originally posted by darthgoober
That wasn't the only time Surfer's been in a black hole though. He also entered one to retrieve some of the Elders of the Universe from the realm of Magic, and he's used them numerous times to traverse the universe. Galactus himself has flat out said that Surfer is capable of surviving...

What comic and issue# for the elders thing?

As for travelling...isn't wormholes and not black holes?

Originally posted by Priest
i agree, its only quan that uses that argument.

How is it a handibap? It's not like All star gets to use any of his tech in this thread either.

Originally posted by Galan007
Then this should be taken into account before the "Thanos stalemated Odin" argument is used.

Except Thanos didn't stalemate him... he just kinda lasted for awhile before the fight was broken up. 😬

Originally posted by Priest
How bout when Surfer was one shotted by Odin, and thanos took the same shots like nothing.
is that also a testament of surfers versatility?
Alright don't be rediculous, it's entirely different circumstance. That's durability against magic, Surfer and Thanos in a black hole isn't.

Originally posted by Priest
i agree, its only quan that uses that argument.
True lol.

When I think of that battle, all I can think is how much of a low-showing that was on Odin's part.... I have never once though of it as being a "high-showing" for Thanos... Just MO. 🙂

Originally posted by CaptainStoic
Plus he lifted more than a quintillion ton with one arm behind his back.
A/S lifted 200 quintillion tons with one arm actually..... And he did this very easily.

Originally posted by Priest
ur taking away standrad abilities and equipment, its a handicap 🙄

You're talking about healing tech, containment and stuff.
If that was the case, then Superman could just geneti-lock
from his fortress, or a phantom zone projector or something.

Its not a handicap.

Originally posted by CaptainStoic
All Star Superman shook the world while arm wrestling, I have lots of doubts concerning Thanos winning this battle. Plus he lifted more than a quintillion ton with one arm behind his back.
200 quintillion. Not maxing it.