Darth Nihilus vs. Darth Malak

Started by Violent2Dope4 pages

Darth Nihilus vs. Darth Malak

Both are at their primes. Nihilus cannot use Force Killer.

1st match: Pure sabers

2nd match: Force fight

3rd match: All out

Fight takes place at a graveyard of planets on Malachor V.

1 Malak- was called a skilled duelist, more than Nihilus can say
2 Nihilus- Holding the Ravager together speaks to his power
3 don't know, I'll wait to see what other people say

Originally posted by tulakhordpwns
2 Nihilus- Holding the Leviathan together speaks to his power

He held the Ravager together.

That would actually be a good and long duel, unlike if Nilihus went against Luke, that would be a quick death for Luke. So i say they would kill each other most likely, otherwise maybe Nilihus if he got the opportunity...really that's all it comes down too...opportunities, because...like i told Hord...it is never a sure thing in battle.

1. Likely Malak.

2. Nihilus, and I don't need a damn reason.

3. Nihilus, he would be dropping entire ships on Malak's head and is vastly more powerful in the Force.

To Sparrow, Luke>Everyone in SW.

Originally posted by Darth Sparrow
That would actually be a good and long duel, unlike if Nilihus went against Luke, that would be a quick death for Luke. So i say they would kill each other most likely, otherwise maybe Nilihus if he got the opportunity...really that's all it comes down too...opportunities, because...like i told Hord...it is never a sure thing in battle.

That depends on which Luke you're talking about.. NJO Luke would certainly NOT be going down against Nihilus, while Nihilus would OWN ESB or RotJ Luke.

1-We can't say, we don't know enough about Nihilus do determine his lightsaber abilities.

2-Nihilus owns on this one.

3-I'm tempted to say Nihilus because of his incredible Force powers, but I can't say because I don't know how good he was with the saber.. if he was good enough to hold off Malak for a while, though, then I think this would give him a chance to destroy him with his Force powers.

Re: Darth Nihilus vs. Darth Malak

Originally posted by Violent2Dope
Both are at their primes. Nihilus cannot use Force Killer.

1st match: Pure sabers

2nd match: Force fight

3rd match: All out

Fight takes place at a graveyard of planets on Malachor V.

Saber fight likely goes to Malak. Nihilus never displayed anything impressive.

Force fight? A wtfpwnage for Nihilus. Not only does he have his drain, but they are on Malachor V, where he gained his uber power. NO contest..

All out? Also goes to Nihilus. Unless Malak can get close enough to him to unleash one of his many powers, he's drained.

Re: Re: Darth Nihilus vs. Darth Malak

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
Saber fight likely goes to Malak. Nihilus never displayed anything impressive.

Force fight? A wtfpwnage for Nihilus. Not only does he have his drain, but they are on Malachor V, where he gained his uber power. NO contest..

All out? Also goes to Nihilus. Unless Malak can get close enough to him to unleash one of his many powers, he's drained.

I took "Force Killer"(It is not a damn drain) off. Also,I forgot to mention that neither get a boost from Malachor V lol.

Well, technically it is a drain. He uses it to feed on the life force of people and planets.

Even without Force Drain / Death Field, Nihilus still stomps Malak in a Force Duel and wins in an all-out duel. Not sure about the saber duel, malak might have that.

I'd probably give even the full-out fight to Malak. If Nihilus was the type to drop ships on people, why did he lost to the trio on the Ravager? I contend that Malak was the second most powerful Sith of his time and therefor defeats Nihilus.

Originally posted by -Blasmaster-
Well, technically it is a drain. He uses it to feed on the life force of people and planets.
No, he does not kill planets, only their inhabitants. He instantly creates Force Bonds with his victims, and in that instant violently severs them, and feeds on the death it causes. Also, Nihilus lost to the trio on the ravager cause not only was he weakened from his hunger, but he was weakened again when he tried to Force Kill the Exile, which backfired cause Exile was also a Wound in the Force. Notice that when they confront him, Nihilus, despite already being weakened, with a mere gesture sends the Exile to her knees, and could have easily killed her, but tried to Force Kill her instead.

me>Luke

Nihilus wins

Originally posted by Violent2Dope
No, he does not kill planets, only their inhabitants. He instantly creates Force Bonds with his victims, and in that instant violently severs them, and feeds on the death it causes. Also, Nihilus lost to the trio on the ravager cause not only was he weakened from his hunger, but he was weakened again when he tried to Force Kill the Exile, which backfired cause Exile was also a Wound in the Force. Notice that when they confront him, Nihilus, despite already being weakened, with a mere gesture sends the Exile to her knees, and could have easily killed her, but tried to Force Kill her instead.

No. He doesn't just feed on the inhabitants of a planet he feeds on the planet's life-force itself. Look at Katarr. And I assume your talking to Glentract about Nihilus losing to the trio, because I never included anything like that in my previous post. I'm just pointing out that the Force Killer is a form of drain. Feeding on the death the Force Killer causes means feeding on the Life-Force of people and planets. He especially likes feeding on Force-Sensitives beings and planets because of the Force inside them.

Originally posted by -Blasmaster-
No. He doesn't just feed on the inhabitants of a planet he feeds on the planet's life-force itself. Look at Katarr. And I assume your talking to Glentract about Nihilus losing to the trio, because I never included anything like that in my previous post. I'm just pointing out that the Force Killer is a form of drain. Feeding on the death the Force Killer causes means feeding on the Life-Force of people and planets. He especially likes feeding on Force-Sensitives beings and planets because of the Force inside them.
Well it was stated by kreia he feeds on the death his technique causes when he cuts his victims off the force.

As for katarr i believed he used the life drain technique as you mentioned out

1- Malak, Nihilus hasn't shown anything impressive with a saber

2- Nihilus pwns him

3- Nihilus pwns him

Originally posted by -Blasmaster-
No. He doesn't just feed on the inhabitants of a planet he feeds on the planet's life-force itself. Look at Katarr. And I assume your talking to Glentract about Nihilus losing to the trio, because I never included anything like that in my previous post. I'm just pointing out that the Force Killer is a form of drain. Feeding on the death the Force Killer causes means feeding on the Life-Force of people and planets. He especially likes feeding on Force-Sensitives beings and planets because of the Force inside them.
Wrong. A drain does just that, it drains, and nowhere has it been stated that he drains the planet itself, otherwise it could not exist on its own, and it was stated by Visas that her planet still orbits in space.

Nihilus doesn't drain the actual planet, he just drains all of the life on the planet (creates echos in the force, echos kill life, he feeds on the death his echos cause..or something like that lol).
Malak can easily best Nihilus with a saber, but Nihilus can make Malak die 1000 different ways by using the force lol. Overall, probably Nihilus would win, but i'm not sure because i still think Malak's force abilities are better then Nihilus's Lightsaber skills.

Yes, Nihilus didn't show anything impressive about his lightsaber abilities, I give you that.