Obi-Wan Kenobi vs. Darth Bane

Started by Darth Scythe4 pages

Obi-Wan Kenobi vs. Darth Bane

Its Kenobi post ROTS around the time he pwned A'sharad so he's been meditating in the desert for a bit. Versus Bane after Ruusan right before he gets his orbalisks.

Its an all out fight that takes place in the jungles of Felucia.

Hm..

I'm gonna go with Obi-Wan, but by a long LONG shot.

Wait.. is this force included? Never mind he just gets trashed, then.

Yeah its all out. Sabers/Force included.

Bane wins, but close.

Close? I don't think so. Bane takes this by a large margin.

Obi-Wan puts up laughable resistant, and Bane wins pretty easily, even though Obi-Wan would be the only Jedi Bane's ever fought

Bane wins, but only because of the better Force powers.

Darth Bane

Bane wins.

In a saber fight I've gotta give the slight edge to Kenobi. But overall Bane is superior to Obi-Wan, so he wins.

seeing hteres force bane would just use force crush

Obi Wan takes it in a close fight. How strong is Bane? I doubt that he's as strong as Dooku. I've read through POD and other than the fact that it's not one of the best novels - even in SW - I never got the impression Bane would crash someone like Obi Wan with the force.

Unless we're saying Bane by this point was stronger than ROTS Anakin in the force? The same Anakin that could bring down ceilings with a scream and lift objects weighing tons with ease.

All I'm saying is Bane doesn't seem to have Dooku's level of force mastery, and I could see him get himself beat down by Obi Wan in a lightsaber duel.

Lol, you're crazy. I'd even argue that Quordis - the guy that Bane utterly tooled with the force - would be beyond Obi-Wan in the force, simply because of his statues in his order, and the fact that as a natural force spirit, he was still able to use the force whereas Obi-Wan couldn't do squat.

That's assuming the whole Qordis being a spirit wasn't retconned. Oops, it was!

Since when exactly? Quit making shit up.

Originally posted by Proteus
Since when exactly? Quit making shit up.

Since POD came out. No qordis ghost, no Kaan ghost, no Freedon Nadd holocron, etc..

How does PoD retcon the part of BotS where Quordis appears as a spirit a spirit?

Originally posted by Proteus
How does PoD retcon the part of BotS where Quordis appears as a spirit a spirit?

Because apparently he didn't go to Onderon and find out the rule of two, which would rule out any of that stuff I said, from happening.

And claiming that quordis is stronger than obi wan simply because of his status is absurd seeing that every apprentice is a "sith lord" in the brotherhood of darkness

Actually, it was that coupled along with how powerful his spirit was, and no, not every Apprentice is a Sith Lord in the Brotherhood; the most talented students became Dark Lords towards the end of the war, and that was because not only had they become as powerful as most of the Dark Lords within the BoD, but because the BoD needed more of them on the Battlefield. Quordis, being the head of the most important Academy, and one of the top 3 sith, is very powerful.

Yet when Bane applied a force choke on him, his force defence was described as being torn away by Bane's attack as if it wasn't even there. bane absoultely demolished Quordis with the force, and he'd do the same to Obi-Wan.

Sexy, I really have no idea what you're talking about. PoD doesn't make note of anything that takes place after the book at all, so I don't know where you got the idea that he 'apparently didn't go to Onderon' from.