Originally posted by abhilegend
Red herrings and strawman arguments?I accepted your BZ, if you're so sure surfer can beat embodiment of universe Kiss, why don't you take the challenge and prove surfer beats Superman?
Yes Abhi, both of those things are examples of logical fallacies. Glad to see you're familiarizing yourself with the concept since it'll hopefully save me a few rebuttal posts.
Originally posted by abhilegend
And Goober my boy, why don't you start your argument here to why Surfer wins here. Feats, statements, anything.You show me what you got, I'll show you how proper debating using comics work and not "This is what surfer can do" nonsense.
No point in start here and then having to start all over again come game time.
Now as far as judge selection goes, how do you feel about my suggestions of Digi, Newjack, Galan, Scoobless, and leonidas? I haven't talked to any of them about doing yet cause I didn't want to get their hopes up if the bottom fell out, but they're normally up for judging with a little notice.
Would you prefer that the match be ended by post limit or time limit? Personally I think a 72 hour time limit would make it easier all around since the topic is so monumental and we wouldn't have to worry about counting each letter we're typing, but I'm not outright opposed to doing that way.
Also, when's a good starting date for you?
Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Forget your panel of judges..Digi's racist, Newjack has man-dates with Digi, leo is a hack, Galan is a quitter, and god only knows what goes on in Scoob's mind.
I recommend Rao Kal el, Time Imm, Lord of Bklyn, Boardwlkr, and Prof T McCabe as judges because aside from being very unbiased, they are also all pro debaters... Correction... Master-debaters! <--- Especially on all things Supermeng.....
😏
👆
The 2nd best judges ever.
Originally posted by darthgoober
Yes Abhi, both of those things are examples of logical fallacies. Glad to see you're familiarizing yourself with the concept since it'll hopefully save me a few rebuttal posts.No point in start here and then having to start all over again come game time.
Now as far as judge selection goes, how do you feel about my suggestions of Digi, Newjack, Galan, Scoobless, and leonidas? I haven't talked to any of them about doing yet cause I didn't want to get their hopes up if the bottom fell out, but they're normally up for judging with a little notice.
Would you prefer that the match be ended by post limit or time limit? Personally I think a 72 hour time limit would make it easier all around since the topic is so monumental and we wouldn't have to worry about counting each letter we're typing, but I'm not outright opposed to doing that way.
Also, when's a good starting date for you?
Those are the best, non biased judges on KMC. Rubbing hands together...Can't wait for this.
Originally posted by Surtur
I'd just rather see people do a scan off to settle it once and for all.
Originally posted by quanchi112
It will never be settled even after goober wins.
Yeah it'll likely never be settled in the mind of Abhi and myself, but a good solo debate with judges and with the day to day BS cut out can have massive impacts on the forum as a whole. Just look at how the forum consensus shifted after the first ever BZ between Trick and myself. This time I'm mostly arguing to disprove the common opinion that "Surfer can only beat Supes because of weakness exploitation".
Originally posted by darthgoober
Yes Abhi, both of those things are examples of logical fallacies. Glad to see you're familiarizing yourself with the concept since it'll hopefully save me a few rebuttal posts.
😂
They aren't. Only yours is. I'll let you figure it out yourself. If not, worry not. I'm always here to help.
Translation: I'm too chicken to accept the challenge.No point in start here and then having to start all over again come game time.
Now as far as judge selection goes, how do you feel about my suggestions of Digi, Newjack, Galan, Scoobless, and leonidas? I haven't talked to any of them about doing yet cause I didn't want to get their hopes up if the bottom fell out, but they're normally up for judging with a little notice.
Would you prefer that the match be ended by post limit or time limit? Personally I think a 72 hour time limit would make it easier all around since the topic is so monumental and we wouldn't have to worry about counting each letter we're typing, but I'm not outright opposed to doing that way.
Also, when's a good starting date for you?
First accept my challenge or concede Superman beats surfer going by comics . I don't play by your rules.
You play by mine.
Originally posted by darthgoober
Yeah it'll likely never be settled in the mind of Abhi and myself, but a good solo debate with judges and with the day to day BS cut out can have massive impacts on the forum as a whole. Just look at how the forum consensus shifted after the first ever BZ between Trick and myself. This time I'm mostly arguing to disprove the common opinion that "Surfer can only beat Supes because of weakness exploitation".
Accept my challenge or concede Superman beats surfer going by comics.
You can't have your cake and eat it too.
Originally posted by abhilegend
😂They aren't. Only yours is. I'll let you figure it out yourself. If not, worry not. I'm always here to help.
Originally posted by abhilegend
Translation: I'm too chicken to accept the challenge.
Originally posted by abhilegend
First accept my challenge or concede Superman beats surfer going by comics . I don't play by your rules.You play by mine.
We're talking about a match that "goes by comics" Abhi, comics are what KMC rules are based around. If that's your only stipulation then it's built right into my challenge and there's nothing to keep us from moving on to the BZ lol.
Originally posted by darthgoober
Red herrings and strawman arguments AREN'T examples of logical fallacies?
Superman beating surfer via better combat feats isn't either. Surfer beating Kismet is.
Of course you're declining the challenge. Let me know when you're ready. We'll do BZ after you take my challenge.I'm not declining a challenge, I'm declining starting our match early here in this thread silly lol
No, we are not. We are going to use an imaginary version of both characters which can use whatever abilities they have in conjunction like they never have in comics.We're talking about a match that "goes by comics" Abhi, comics are what KMC rules are based around.
If that's your only stipulation then it's built right into my challenge and there's nothing to keep us from moving on to the BZ lol.
Only comic fights against other characters will be used.
Are you OK with that?
Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Forget your panel of judges..Digi's racist, Newjack has man-dates with Digi, leo is a hack, Galan is a quitter, and god only knows what goes on in Scoob's mind.
I recommend Rao Kal el, Time Imm, Lord of Bklyn, Boardwlkr, and Prof T McCabe as judges because aside from being very unbiased, they are also all pro debaters... Correction... Master-debaters! <--- Especially on all things Supermeng.....
😏
I recommend Zom to be a judge. Digi and Scoobs on a less serious note.
😏