mr mxy vs parallax(hal)&ion(kyle)

Started by Val3 pages
Val Senior Member

Originally posted by Avlon
Joker didn't think particularly much of you either.

Can't we all just get along? 🙂


No.

Shin_Nikkolas Restricted

Since when did World's Funnest become canon now?

TricksterPriest Renegade Timelord
Originally posted by Shin_Nikkolas
Since when did World's Funnest become canon now?

It's canon for Mxy. Hypertime ftw.

Shin_Nikkolas Restricted

Nope.

52 universes.

Thus, only certain Elseworlds are canon.

Nothing says World's Funnest is.

Thanks and please try again later.

Avlon Godot Brew#107
Originally posted by Val
No.

Not even for your Doaky-poo?

Val Senior Member

Anything for Doakes. droolio

Merlyn Order Of...

Originally posted by Shin_Nikkolas
Nope.

52 universes.

Thus, only certain Elseworlds are canon.

Nothing says World's Funnest is.

Ahhh... So YOU'LL decide which Elseworlds titles are canon, and which are not?

That literally made me giggle a bit.

Shin_Nikkolas Restricted

Ahhh... So YOU'LL decide which Elseworlds titles are canon, and which are not?

That literally made me giggle a bit.

Oh...I DIDN'T say that?

You are literally laughing at what you said?

Nice.

Let's now actually look at what I said.

Thus, only certain Elseworlds are canon.

Oh...it seems like I'm stating a truism. Afterall, Kingdom Come was an Elseworld but LOOK! It's canon as another of the 52 universes!

But where is it said World's Funnest is?

Nowhere?

Okay then.

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Mxy.

nvrbeenwthagirl Restricted

Originally posted by Shin_Nikkolas
Nope.

52 universes.

Thus, only certain Elseworlds are canon.

Nothing says World's Funnest is.

Thanks and please try again later.


The kingdom still exist. Mentioned in 52. World's Funnest is still cannon until further notice. Plus we all know Grant morrison loves hypertime and guess who happens to be in charge of the next big Crisis?

Soljer Beware my Power

It doesn't matter. Kingdom come has concrete evidence of being canon. Something that world's funnest lacks. There is no reason to believe it to be canon - well, no reason except for spite or bias.

Val Senior Member

Originally posted by Soljer
It doesn't matter. Kingdom come has concrete evidence of being canon. Something that world's funnest lacks. There is no reason to believe it to be canon - well, no reason except for spite or bias.

Don't you get it? Grant Morrison <3 Hypertime and since Grant Morrison is writing Crisis, that means it's canon. My logic is infallible and if you can't see that, you're an elitist. nuts

TricksterPriest Renegade Timelord
Originally posted by Soljer
It doesn't matter. Kingdom come has concrete evidence of being canon. Something that world's funnest lacks. There is no reason to believe it to be canon - well, no reason except for spite or bias.

Actually, I'm reasonably sure Galan had a 5 page arguement with Mr. M about this, and he proved Hypertime is canon, and that WF is canon because of it.

Shin_Nikkolas Restricted

Hypertime is obviously canon but that doesn't mean World's Funnest is.

FACT: There are 52 universes ONLY. No more, no less.

FACT: There are over a hundred Elseworld comics, each taking place in some alternate universe.

So, it's frankly impossible to have every single Elseworlds be canon.

TricksterPriest Renegade Timelord

Originally posted by Shin_Nikkolas
Hypertime is obviously canon but that doesn't mean World's Funnest is.

FACT: There are 52 universes ONLY. No more, no less.

FACT: There are over a hundred Elseworld comics, each taking place in some alternate universe.

So, it's frankly impossible to have every single Elseworlds be canon.

But WF occured BEFORE IC and the 52 universes. So your logic doesn't work. doped

Shin_Nikkolas Restricted

So did Kingdom Come.

But look. Now it's Earth-22.

Go figure.

Astner The Ghost Who Walks

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
But WF occured BEFORE IC and the 52 universes. So your logic doesn't work. doped

You're wrong, World's Funnest was printed in the 90's, as were Crisis on Infinite earth took place in the 80's.

Soljer Beware my Power
Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Actually, I'm reasonably sure Galan had a 5 page arguement with Mr. M about this, and he proved Hypertime is canon, and that WF is canon because of it.

"Galan says so!" doesn't fly here - not with me, anyways. Is an elseworlds comic canon?

Sure. If there's evidence in the mainstream universe.

If Mxy's chatting with Clark and says something like "Oh, alright, I'll just go destroy everything again," you would have a case.

As is, you have a hope and a prayer.

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Originally posted by Soljer
"Galan says so!" doesn't fly here
In the words of another member, whom shall not be named -- How dare you besmirch my name!! durfist

nvrbeenwthagirl Restricted

Originally posted by Soljer
"Galan says so!" doesn't fly here - not with me, anyways. Is an elseworlds comic canon?

Sure. If there's evidence in the mainstream universe.

If Mxy's chatting with Clark and says something like "Oh, alright, I'll just go destroy everything again," you would have a case.

As is, you have a hope and a prayer.


Since there is only one Spectre Prime and One Mxy, World's funnest has to be cannon to those characters. And since Mxy basically erased everything and set it all back to the way it was, EVEN after infinite Earth's had been destroyed, It could have happened at ANY POINT in comics history. or at all points since time has absolutely no meaning to mxy.