Is mace windu underrated?

its obvious, man.

Nothing is obvious unless proven.

The only axiom in Star wars is that Jedi = Good. Sith = Bad.

so, in your opinion, what would have happened had the duel remained a saber duel?

Dunno... Yoda had a disadvantage in taking care of OB1 and Anakin (some attachment eh!).

taking care?

Yoda beats everyone.

How can it be in doubt??

This is the correct top list:
*Darth Vader (ep. 5) (he is the best - he could have taken Sidious out any time he wanted - but he was to busy finding Luke)
*Yoda
*Darth Sidious
*Luke (ep. 6)
*Anakin Skywalker (ep. 3, just before turned in to DV)
*Windu
*Dooku
*Obi-Wan

It is rubbish that Sidious won against Yoda (watch the fight again - it was a draw, but it is clear that Yoda was more powerful. The problem was that they fight at a place were Yoda had to win fast - Sidious was at his "home place" and could get a lot of help if Yoda didn't finish him off fast.

And yes - Yoda failed - He should have killed Sidious. But he did not loose the fight against Sidious - that is ridiculous.

- it was also a draw agains Dooku, but again - if one look closely I think he was more powerful).

Lucas could have done a better job here (telling us who is the best) - but then we would have nothing to discuss... 🙂

the correct list? on whose authority?

That should be labeled the incorrect list. RotJ Luke should be at the bottom, and Sidious should be at the top. Then put ep 5 Vader under Sids and Yoda.

mmm....matter of opinion.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
the correct list? on whose authority?

Lucas made sure that it is impossible to make a list where we all will agree.

One have to watch the movies and then it is up to each person to make a power list.

"The correct list" was just to provoke others to make a list too. It is always exiting to see what other people think.

The list is of course my opinion.

Originally posted by Antaeus
Lucas made sure that it is impossible to make a list where we all will agree.

One have to watch the movies and then it is up to each person to make a power list.

"The correct list" was just to provoke others to make a list too. It is always exiting to see what other people think.

The list is of course my opinion.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
so it is "the correct list" only in your mind, yes?

This is my correct list - you probably got your correct list.

Lucas made sure that we never will agree of a correct list.

Got it 😉

yes, I got it. it's just that you referred it as the correct ist, as if you had decreed it so.

Correct list? WOOOOHAHAHAHAHA

exactly....correct list indeed. wanker

There's no such thing.

thats what I just said.

Originally posted by queeq
There's no such thing.

I do agree, but I got my correct list.

But I already did write that - you may have missed that 😛

This is the correct top list:
*Darth Vader (ep. 5) (he is the best - he could have taken Sidious out any time he wanted - but he was to busy finding Luke)

For a second, I thought you were trying to be serious.