The Punisher: agree or disagree?

Originally posted by tjcoady
God, no. Not even remotely would I ever, ever be alright with the Punisher existing in real life. He's an adolescent power fantasy. Dear God, I would never, ever condone someone acting the same way as he is. Slaughtering people he judges to be corrupt without a trial? Jesus. That would be terrifying.

Then again, I'm opposed to the state slaughtering people too. I don't think the government should have a right to decide who lives or dies, so I'm pretty against some lunatic with a background in the Marines and a lot of artillery killing people too.

Kill all evil.

Originally posted by tjcoady
God, no. Not even remotely would I ever, ever be alright with the Punisher existing in real life. He's an adolescent power fantasy. Dear God, I would never, ever condone someone acting the same way as he is. Slaughtering people he judges to be corrupt without a trial? Jesus. That would be terrifying.

Then again, I'm opposed to the state slaughtering people too. I don't think the government should have a right to decide who lives or dies, so I'm pretty against some lunatic with a background in the Marines and a lot of artillery killing people too.

But the thing is dude what if some scum came and tried and kill you and your family and the punisher showed up and saved your bacon it was either going to be you or them man would you be terrified that your life was just saved even though the means were not to your liking?

It's like i don't really condone killing either but sometimes you do have to fight fire with fire so in my opinion sometimes it can be justified cause it's either you or them.

I actually agree.

He is avenging the death of his family and dealing with justice the way is should be dealt.

Originally posted by Passione
I actually agree.

He is avenging the death of his family and dealing with justice the way is should be dealt.

I'm actually glad that other people agree with Castle's approach to justice. He's cleaning up the streets.

He's killing people for nothing.

If he would just ease down on the lesser criminals, I would be cool with it.

Originally posted by Grinning Goku
I'm actually glad that other people agree with Castle's approach to justice. He's cleaning up the streets.

And doing it with such style..

Originally posted by llagrok
He's killing people for nothing.

If he would just ease down on the lesser criminals, I would be cool with it.

Originally posted by Passione
And doing it with such style..

In a way he is saving the poilce time and money..

But honestly killing the lesser ones might be unfair.

Maybe maiming them for life is more suitable.

Originally posted by Tommy05
I am in love lol.

But honestly killing the lesser ones might be unfair.

Maybe maiming them for life is more suitable.

Okay so kill the rapists, serial killers child abusers etc.. and just injure the other ones..

I suggest either breaking their legs of their fingers..

Originally posted by Passione
Okay so kill the rapists, serial killers child abusers etc.. and just injure the other ones..

I suggest either breaking their legs of their fingers..

I say legs. Fingers aren't enough. Maybe bust a kneecap or two. ✅

Originally posted by Passione
Okay so kill the rapists, serial killers child abusers etc.. and just injure the other ones..

I suggest either breaking their legs of their fingers..

That's the thing, he kills them all.

The guilty must be punished. All you liberal weenies need to go hold hands and sing Kum ba yah somewhere else. durfist

Originally posted by Badabing
The guilty must be punished. All you liberal weenies need to go hold hands and sing Kum ba yah somewhere else. durfist

"The guilty must be punished." Well you're guilty of highly irrational and morally bankrupt thinking, maybe Punisher should shoot you too 😉

Originally posted by tjcoady
God, no. Not even remotely would I ever, ever be alright with the Punisher existing in real life. He's an adolescent power fantasy. Dear God, I would never, ever condone someone acting the same way as he is. Slaughtering people he judges to be corrupt without a trial? Jesus. That would be terrifying.

Then again, I'm opposed to the state slaughtering people too. I don't think the government should have a right to decide who lives or dies, so I'm pretty against some lunatic with a background in the Marines and a lot of artillery killing people too.

They have a wi-fi connection in your drum circle Sean Penn? 😛

Originally posted by willRules
"The guilty must be punished." Well you're guilty of highly irrational and morally bankrupt thinking, maybe Punisher should shoot you too 😉

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
They have a wi-fi connection in your drum circle Sean Penn? 😛

Originally posted by Badabing
Shoot me? 😆 The Punisher and I are paisanos you dunderhead. Now, go back to your camp fire is continue the Kum ba yah song.

Oh I see you and Punisher have a connection do you? Is it that you're Paisanos, or more likely the fact that you justify you're intellectually stunted, morally bankrupt attitude by calling others liberal hippies and blowing their brains out. Or could this connection be a much greater one I wonder? I remember the Wolverine issue where it was implied that the Punisher was a homosexual, maybe this explains the connection you share with him ✅ To be honest with you I'd rather be a liberal hippie than a morally bankrupt, simple minded, irrational psychopath with blatant homosexual undertones 😛

As for calling me a dunderhead, well....... you're a poo head! 😛

Originally posted by willRules
Oh I see you and Punisher have a connection do you? Is it that you're Paisanos, or more likely the fact that you justify you're intellectually stunted, morally bankrupt attitude by calling others liberal hippies and blowing their brains out. Or could this connection be a much greater one I wonder? I remember the Wolverine issue where it was implied that the Punisher was a homosexual, maybe this explains the connection you share with him ✅ To be honest with you I'd rather be a liberal hippie than a morally bankrupt, simple minded, irrational psychopath with blatant homosexual undertones 😛

As for calling me a dunderhead, well....... you're a poo head! 😛

I can't tell if you're an over the top emo who is actually being serious or just playing. Either way, liberal weenies are vehemently against judgements on people. Intellectually stunted and morally bankrupt....You're the one who said "maybe Punisher should shoot you too ".crylaugh This topic is about COMICS you dunderhead. Keep your fantasies about Wolverine and Frank to yourself weirdo! 😘

Poo head! durfist You're Mr. Pee Pee Pants!!!!!111

Originally posted by tjcoady
God, no. Not even remotely would I ever, ever be alright with the Punisher existing in real life. He's an adolescent power fantasy. Dear God, I would never, ever condone someone acting the same way as he is. Slaughtering people he judges to be corrupt without a trial? Jesus. That would be terrifying.

Then again, I'm opposed to the state slaughtering people too. I don't think the government should have a right to decide who lives or dies, so I'm pretty against some lunatic with a background in the Marines and a lot of artillery killing people too.

i'd condone it in certain situations. In "the slavers" for example, the punisher killed an organization that trafficked women, raped them, and killed babies. The government and FBI couldn't touch them, so he did it for them.
people like that deserve it IMO...

Originally posted by llagrok
He's killing people for nothing.

If he would just ease down on the lesser criminals, I would be cool with it.

he is a bit hardcore with gangsters and street thugs i'll admit. they're not exactly saints though.

the best example of that was in "up is down and black is white."
In it, there was this mafia guy that desecrated on his families grave, So Punisher responded by going on a killing spree against typical gangsters and mafia.

to me though, i can't blame him for that. plus, Crime went down because they were too scared afterwards

Recently, i've only seen him go after the "big crime" people instead of robbers or agressive drivers.

Originally posted by willRules
"The guilty must be punished." Well you're guilty of highly irrational and morally bankrupt thinking, maybe Punisher should shoot you too 😉

rapists, pedophiles, murderers, traffickers, etc..
people that do that level of crime should definately be dealt with.

And if the law couldn't touch them, then Why wouldn't it be ok for the punisher to take them down?

"the guilty must be punished." it could certainly be more specific about what "guilty" is, but it's a pretty good philosophy.