OMG! HUGE thought

Ok, I'm sure my logic's off so someone will have to correct me on this, but I think I found a loophole to the curse. We're all unhappy Will is bound forever, right? Sparrabethers, willabethers, norribethers, we're all in agreement on this. So I think I know something.

Why does Elizabeth have to keep the heart safe?

If someone stabs Will's heart, isn't he free? I don't think it actually killed Davy. I think what happened to Davy is that Calypso just took him with her, because she's not really dead. She's immortal and Davy had a look of relief on his face and said her name like they could be together now. So I think stabbing the heart just makes the captain powerless. So Elizabeth could just have someone else stab the heart (and it's not like it's against her nature to do that), and free Will.

I'm up for that. Totally. Good thought! I always had a joke that she was just waiting for the kid to grow old enough to stab the heart himself, so she and Will could have some privacy. 😉

Wow, Elizabeth Swann: the Andrea Yates of the POTC world. That's just so dark...and yet if young immortal Will Junior happened to come across a mermaid or something...

I think that would be cool to pass it on. So the one person wouldn't have to live forever seeing everyone they love die 😄

If you stab the heart you kill the captain.

Originally posted by SelinaAndBruce
If you stab the heart you kill the captain.

well, i'm good with that.

Im good with it, too. haha

Ya someone should try it and if it ends up killing him...so be it!! 🙂 oh my we r evil!

No Will and Elizabeth are destiny though 🙁 It's not a perfect destiny but it's theirs and I think no matter what Elizabeth will always come back to that cliff for Will

Ya because she feels she has too, she promised and because she does love Will she'll do it for his sake. I do believe that even if Elizabeth and Jack were to be together, once every 10 years she would stand on that cliff to see Will because she honors her promises not because she still loves him. and Jack would understand...thats my opinion.

you know what i love about sparrabethers? we are endlessly creative. totally undaunted. fully committed. it's fantastic. Elizabeth is married with a kid, and we STILL have NO problem coming up with endless scenarios how Jack and Elizabeth could STILL make it work. haha. i love it. 🙂

Yea I think tht stabbing the heart wuld kill the captain... 🙁 but if there's a land of the dead than maybe Elizabeth could tell her kid tht once she gets old and dies tht he should stab the heart... tht way Will and Liz could be together, but cut neither one of their lives short... and Will probably wouldn't mind dying if Liz was already dead...

Originally posted by katelovespirate
you know what i love about sparrabethers? we are endlessly creative. totally undaunted. fully committed. it's fantastic. Elizabeth is married with a kid, and we STILL have NO problem coming up with endless scenarios how Jack and Elizabeth could STILL make it work. haha. i love it. 🙂

No but for real I don't want Jack committing adultery with Liz either. Elizabeth and Will belong to each other. They're married to one another they have a son together and I believe she will wait for him faithfully because at the end of the day her main objective in all the Pirates movies no matter what she did was to save Will and to be with him eventually. They went to the ends of the earth for one another and Elizabeth even sacrificed Jack so she and Will could get away with the other crew members.

I'm not a hard core Willabether at all but they are the love story in this series and I have no doubt Elizabeth will continue to wait for Will because the moment she was assigned to watch over him on that ship they became the ones for each other.

so r u a wallabether?

Originally posted by potcfan2003
so r u a wallabether?

Originally posted by SelinaAndBruce
That's called desperation 😉 No just kidding I do admire the spin cycle you guys maintain

No but for real I don't want Jack committing adultery with Liz either. Elizabeth and Will belong to each other. They're married to one another they have a son together and I believe she will wait for him faithfully because at the end of the day her main objective in all the Pirates movies no matter what she did was to save Will and to be with him eventually. They went to the ends of the earth for one another and Elizabeth even sacrificed Jack so she and Will could get away with the other crew members.

I'm not a hard core Willabether at all but they are the love story in this series and I have no doubt Elizabeth will continue to wait for Will because the moment she was assigned to watch over him on that ship they became the ones for each other.

haha... no, i think most sparrabethers don't want Elizabeth to cheat on Will at all... we much prefer to come up with reasons why Will sets her free (or dies, not because we are heartless, but because the way the film ended, it's not like they were happily together anyways).

and really, i think most sparrabethers are big fans of both characters (Jack and Elizabeth) individually and find it more challenging and exciting to watch them interact. Anything you see between Jack and Elizabeth will never, never be the kind of mushy, kissy, sweet, innocent romance like Will and Elizabeth have, or most couples have for that matter. It's much more intriguing and complicated- in that it challenges morality, challenges defined roles, involves a lot of physical attraction, and boils down to two people who are obsessed with freedom and adventure. but don't take my word for it. 😉

i think the best way to understand a Sparrabethers continued hope despite AWE, read the link to the fanfic Willo posted on the Sparrabeth thread. It's long, but WORTH IT, even if you don't ship sparrabeth. extremely well written and fun to read. The only problem is it's not finished yet, leaving you on a massive cliff hanger. haha.

oops... I meant willabether! OMG and u like Will too? I like Will better than Elizabeth... she's one of my least fav. characters... but I still love her charcter...

Originally posted by potcfan2003
oops... I meant willabether! OMG and u like Will too? I like Will better than Elizabeth... she's one of my least fav. characters... but I still love her charcter...

Originally posted by willofthewisp
Ok, I'm sure my logic's off so someone will have to correct me on this, but I think I found a loophole to the curse. We're all unhappy Will is bound forever, right? Sparrabethers, willabethers, norribethers, we're all in agreement on this. So I think I know something.

Why does Elizabeth have to keep the heart safe?

If someone stabs Will's heart, isn't he free? I don't think it actually killed Davy. I think what happened to Davy is that Calypso just took him with her, because she's not really dead. She's immortal and Davy had a look of relief on his face and said her name like they could be together now. So I think stabbing the heart just makes the captain powerless. So Elizabeth could just have someone else stab the heart (and it's not like it's against her nature to do that), and free Will.

well...call me evil but I'm not all that upset that Will is bound to the Dutchman forever.....it actually gives a loophole for Sparrabeth...but I won't go over those reasons again...I've already done so quite a few times on the Sparrabeth thread.....in fact, us sparrabethers over at Tasty Pirates were shouting for glee..... 😈 i'm sorry...but I just don't won't Elizabeth and Will together...and I don't think they are destined...fate keep intervening into their "happily" everafter...

Originally posted by lovethemtigers
well...call me evil but I'm not all that upset that Will is bound to the Dutchman forever.....it actually gives a loophole for Sparrabeth...but I won't go over those reasons again...I've already done so quite a few times on the Sparrabeth thread.....in fact, us sparrabethers over at Tasty Pirates were shouting for glee..... 😈 i'm sorry...but I just don't won't Elizabeth and Will together...and I don't think they are destined...fate keep intervening into their "happily" everafter...