Does Anakin's traitor butt belong here?

LoL all this speculation is just Circular Reasoning....Listen iv thought about this...and i belive this is how it is...Ahem...

When Anakin Skywalker went to the Darkside HE DIED...i know its been said But he turned to evil and basically in the case of the Force he....DIED

When Anakin Redeemed himself and appreared as YOUNG ANAKIN SKYWALKER it was a symbol of him becomeing who he once was....hence him appearing as WHO HE ONCE WAS a Young Jedi Knight that fell in love and fell into darkness.

When you redeem you'reself you become who you once were and the scares of you're past are erased as it is with the force....other instances of this are..even tho they dident die....

Bastila - All her Sith Stuff was destroyed and taken away...

If you play KOTOR II and KOTOR I if you go to Darkside you get scar like traits on ur face when you return to the lightside it is reversed...

I know those arent good examples but...JUST THINK ABOUT IT

eh, not bad.

But NO EU!!!! 😠

Yes, I think that is the reasoning. But it doesn't make sense. I kinda totally discard twenty years. I think Old Anakin is much more beautiful too see there, WITH the 'scars' of 20 years and redeemed. Now it's saying, oh well, those 20 years I wasn't quite myself, never mind it.

So I think it's lame.

I do agree, it would be much more meaningful to have the older Anakin...but then would he have his mechanical arms and legs still...would he have stumps...or just stick in body parts.

Not that we would be able to see that under all those robes.

And why would mechanical limbs cross over to the afterlife????

Originally posted by General G
I do agree, it would be much more meaningful to have the older Anakin...but then would he have his mechanical arms and legs still...would he have stumps...or just stick in body parts.

Originally posted by MasterAshenVor
LoL all this speculation is just Circular Reasoning....Listen iv thought about this...and i belive this is how it is...Ahem...

When Anakin Skywalker went to the Darkside HE DIED...i know its been said But he turned to evil and basically in the case of the Force he....DIED

When Anakin Redeemed himself and appreared as YOUNG ANAKIN SKYWALKER it was a symbol of him becomeing who he once was....hence him appearing as WHO HE ONCE WAS a Young Jedi Knight that fell in love and fell into darkness.

When you redeem you'reself you become who you once were and the scares of you're past are erased as it is with the force....other instances of this are..even tho they dident die....

Bastila - All her Sith Stuff was destroyed and taken away...

If you play KOTOR II and KOTOR I if you go to Darkside you get scar like traits on ur face when you return to the lightside it is reversed...

I know those arent good examples but...JUST THINK ABOUT IT

I understand that it is supposed to be a symbol. But it is one that can't logically be explained. Either he redeemed himself and his Robo Body is redeemed or he didn't and nothing happens. To have Young Anakin there is beyond unreasonable.

Originally posted by queeq
Not that we would be able to see that under all those robes.

And why would mechanical limbs cross over to the afterlife????

Just checking.

Sometimes, G.... sometimes....

You really had some water in your circuits or something.

They told me it would make it work better.

Figures that you would believe them.

I didn't...but there wasn't much I could do.

Of course not.

Hey, folks, what about being less pointless and more on topic?

Nah... if we stay this way I can close it. 😈

Ah, so you do enjoy closing threads. And I have no problem going on topic...bring something up.

I don't understand why all the threads here get closed really. Once you close a thread can someone open one with the same topic if they want to discuss it further?

Sure. If you stay on topic. I close them because they wander off to far off topic lands for a few pages. So to keep the order I close them.

If you felt you wante to add something you can ask me to reopen or, yes, start another thread.

Makes sense, wanna reopen my general grievous ones?

Nope.