Originally posted by Bardock42
But you do not become younger.I understand that it is supposed to be a symbol. But it is one that can't logically be explained. Either he redeemed himself and his Robo Body is redeemed or he didn't and nothing happens. To have Young Anakin there is beyond unreasonable.
With his extraordinary midichlorian count and being a force ghost,i guess he can change his looks at will,like what he show to Cade skywalker.
But i think he should be replaced it with Timothy,that guy playing hitman.lol.
Originally posted by beedubaya
I don't have a problem with Hayden, but they should have aged him 20 years with digital ageing software. Doesn't make sense for him to be young again when Obi-Wan and Yoda were both their old selves.
1. Anakin was never the same age as Obi-wan nor Yoda.
2. Both Jedi never used the Dark Side and got physically messed up by it like Anakin was.
3. It didn't make sense for Anakin's ghost to have hair, skin, full body, and Obi-wan's clothes when he died a burnt-up, human/machine hybrid in an oxygen suit.
Originally posted by Forcewielder
2. Both Jedi never used the Dark Side and got physically messed up by it like Anakin was.
Originally posted by Jovan
yes, it's because OB1 and Yoda never went dark that they retained their "looks" as ghosts. Anakin fell and it had him "tainted" forever (Yoda says something along the lines "forever will it dominate your path"😉, so it's logical that his appearance is that of before his fall.
That is some major non-sequitur you got going there. It's cerainly not logical. It might make sense, but it doesn't follow from anything.
Originally posted by Jovan
what's the problem? 😕
Just that I don't think it follows logically from anything that has been said in any of the movies.
I do agree though that there can be explanations as to why it is the way it is. To me, it just looks out of place and a bit idiotic (partly because of the Luke asking "Shit, who is that young dude next to Ben and Yoda"😉
Originally posted by Jovan
I don't see the problem... Ben and Yoda looks like how they died: they were Jedi the entire time, didn't go dark. Anakin did, he fell and that made that his ghost-appearance would look like him before his fall. Sounds logic to me.
Oh, but he redeemed himself before his death, so, by that logic old makes more sense. As I said, no problem though, just...odd and stupid.
Originally posted by Bardock42
Oh, but he redeemed himself before his death, so, by that logic old makes more sense. As I said, no problem though, just...odd and stupid.
Originally posted by JovanThat's how I see it, too. It was more done for marketing then for making sense within the movies.
well, it fitted well into the marketing at the time... new episode underway and the release of the OT on DVD. He got lucky about having some sort of vague explanation in the movies