ESB and ANH question

Started by DiEbyDaGuNZ4 pages

ESB and ANH question

I have a couple questions:

Why doesn't Chewie get a medal at the end of ANH?? and...

Why did Darth vader first try to kill luke, and then give him the job offer and revalation?

Chewie owes Han a life debt, therefore he can't take credibility for herione actions. Also I don't understand your second question.

If your talking about when he tryed to shoot down his fighter in ANH then I think Vader didn't know who he was then. After that I think he was just manipulating Luke.

I still don't understand, and the first part of your response, Dim, made no sense at all.

alot of what I say makes no sense...anyway I edited it.

I think UBH is right for #1, and Dim is right for #2. Vader was trying to break his will, and open his mind to the dark side at the same time, in the light saber fight on Cloud City.

Ahh!! Now I understand the question. Thanx SnarlingCur 🙂

r u guys sure?? or was that jjst trying to explain what dim said?

Positive. +

ok thank u!

No problem.

UBH was right for #1, that's what Lucas originally said. Yet after fan outcries and talk of alien descrimination Carrie Fisher presented Chewie with a medal on MTV, that was in 1997 as part of the Special Edition hype. For #2 it was explained in Shadows that despite Vader desperately wanted Luke to join him on the Dark Side he needed to first test his strength in the force before making such a proposal. If Luke could be easily killed there would be no point in converting him.

ok....

Glad I could help.🙂

well..ur alwasy helping

Thanx. This should be in the OT site.

True

Which is where its going, and don't go into further conversations UNLESS it pertains to the subject.

I saw that MTV scene.I almost cried,it was so emotional.Just kidding.🙂

...............

Chewie was just co-pilot, he didn't really do much did he?
And Vader just didn't realise Luke was his son.