Balance to the force.

Started by Lord Knightfa112 pages

1. arent "true sith" the thing revan found out about and was trying to stop from taking over the galaxy when he disapeared?

2. I wouldnt exactly call the empire chaos. It actually was pretty good harmony. all those troopers working together for a common goal... I mean, there is such a thing as "evil" harmony... but george lucas's word goes above all so....

Originally posted by Ushgarak
Technically speaking GL never canonised it; he doesn't count what the books say as part of his own universe, but someone else's interpretation instead.

Whether you accept it is up to you. So feel free to ignore it.

3. ooo I CAN IGNORE THE BOOKS I DONT LIKE??? YAY!!! I Love this guy!

Originally posted by Lord Knightfa11
1. arent "true sith" the thing revan found out about and was trying to stop from taking over the galaxy when he disapeared?

No one knows what they are. They could be part of the sith species or they could be remnants of the sitm empire or an entirely new faction. so they don't count yet

3. ooo I CAN IGNORE THE BOOKS I DONT LIKE??? YAY!!! I Love this guy!

This is EU so they do count and technically with that logic I could say I hate kotor so Revan is not real 😛 You have understand the difference between GL's star wars and the star wars he authorizes aka the EU.

0 is there any place where revan exists but njo luke is not canon? 😄

1. arent "true sith" the thing revan found out about and was trying to stop from taking over the galaxy when he disapeared?

The vague "true Sith" that Darth Revan supposedly went off to fight is likely another attempt at the incredibly incompetent Drew Karapshyn to further butcher the cosmos with his unbelievable Gary-Stu of a character; meanwhile, in terms of in-universe canon, there is a difference between the Sith Order and the primitive species that shares the same name. Emperor Palpatine and his apprentices were true Dark Lords of the Sith -- legitimate in both name and heritage -- the ancient Sith spirits of Korriban having recognized them as such (specifically in Dark Empire).

2. I wouldnt exactly call the empire chaos. It actually was pretty good harmony. all those troopers working together for a common goal... I mean, there is such a thing as "evil" harmony... but george lucas's word goes above all so....

Restoring balance to the Force does not equate to "removing chaos" on a galactic scale, but rather on a Force-related scale. Sith upset the balance; they are Force-using abominations that quite frankly only exist to ruin peace and prosperity. Palpatine, manifestation of all this, was the true factor that made the Force turn to absolute shit for the Republic and the Jedi, thus balance was restored when Anakin Skywalker killed him at the Battle of Endor.

This is EU so they do count and technically with that logic I could say I hate kotor so Revan is not real You have understand the difference between GL's star wars and the star wars he authorizes aka the EU.

You are twisting Ushgarak's words. As an individual, you are at free liberty to believe whatever you want, however you want to. For the purposes of a debate, however, you can't blindly ignore canon on a whim.

Originally posted by Elite Hunter
Well we have the authors to blame for that but from an in universe explanation there could be a few.

However GL okays all EU stories. You even have to be asked to write a story. It's a pretty exclusive club. Zhan told me that when I met him at a book signing near where I live... Still don't like the guy though... Actually like the guy less, he gave like an hour speech about his rise to being a Star Wars author, a little annoying.

Originally posted by LORD JLRTENJAC
However GL okays all EU stories. You even have to be asked to write a story. It's a pretty exclusive club. Zhan told me that when I met him at a book signing near where I live... Still don't like the guy though... Actually like the guy less, he gave like an hour speech about his rise to being a Star Wars author, a little annoying.

That is a little funny about Zahn. I know people how have been on class trips to see Montel Williams and they same he is a complete @$$ even though they got a cool stuff a few years back. 😕

Emperor Palpatine and his apprentices were true Dark Lords of the Sith -- legitimate in both name and heritage -- the ancient Sith spirits of Korriban having recognized them as such (specifically in Dark Empire).

What about the Sith on Korriban, do they count?
And wasn't Lumiya anouther of Vader's apprentices? Doesn't that make her a Sith.
Finally, considering that the Sith were a bunch of anti-social rebels I doubt wether any contender cares if they're not 'real Sith'. Sith is an ideal, not a race.

Originally posted by Darth Exodus
What about the Sith on Korriban, do they count?
And wasn't Lumiya anouther of Vader's apprentices? Doesn't that make her a Sith.
Shes merely a dark jedi.