Originally posted by Blair WindThe thing is that Nightwing would never really be able to touch Cassie with anything. She's dodged multiple bullets at point blank range. and she'd see what he was doing before he would. Also one might argue Tim is as much of the brains protege as Barbara.
Tim is more of the detective, Richard is more of the athlete/leader, Cassandra is more of the fighter, Jason is more of the (who cares?), and Barbara is more of the brains.They all have an aspect of Bruce's, but not all.
In this case scenario I can see Nightwing winning. Its not pure hand to hand, so Cass does not have the immediate advantage, and I would place Nightwing above her in overall skill with gadgets.