Originally posted by jgiant
I love Pitt and i will soon have all his comic's and almost all of his appearances in other comics. He is a heavey hitter and can hold take down guys like thing and colossus and stalmate guys like hulk. So it pretty much comes down to what guys hulk can take down, seeing as hulk and him are pretty much equal, except Pitt can't increase in strength. Sure he fights harder the more he hurts but he doesn't get stronger. He has rediculous healing factor, but he can't stand up to guys that have power like thor. Pitt would put up a good fight, but thor has power that will eventually overwelm Pitt. It has been argued alot whether or not hulk can beat thor and the general consensus is that thor will beat hulk so the same rule applies here. Just because Pitt has claws doesn't mean he can kill thor with them. I haven't seen enough fights of pitt against people like thor to get a good idea of how this fight would go down, but from what i saw it would be a long drawn out fight, Pitt taking massive amounts of punishment and dishing it out, but thor will eventually hit Pitt with a godforce blow that will end the fight.
This is what people would like you to believe, but this is not a popularity contest, in a real fight with Pitt, Thor would be the one receiving more damage in this fight, Thors flesh is not as durable as Pitts. If you were to remove Mjolnir from Thor, which is a weapon and not truly part of him like his arms or legs, who would come out on top? The only reason the Hulk stood toe to toe with Pitt was because of his healing factor, none of these guys have that. Proffesor hulk began 2 times as strong as he did in years previous to his merged condition.... in the battle that hulk had with Pitt there is no doubt in my mind, or for that matter should be in anyones mind that bruce increased in strength from the begining of the fight to it's end. I'm pretty sure that, that is indicative as to how strong Pitt truly is. Pitt not only stayed even with the hulk in that battle but in many ways he took the fight to Bruce.
You say Thor would beat The Hulk but The Hulk has beaten Thor as well. It is not yet clear who exactly is the top dog amongst these two.
Now let me address this massive amounts of punishment that you were talking about, yes Thor can fly, no thor does not have the durability of Pitt, Pitt has claws Thor has nails.... This would be the classic battle of Bengal Tiger vs Gorilla. The Gorilla has strength but ask any zoologist if they think a silerback could kill a full grown Bengal Tiger, and they would laugh at you. The Gorilla simply doesn't have the tools to deal with the ferocity or the dagger like weapons that the Tiger has on it's hands, or feet.
Thor has been mortally wouded by a broadsword that impaled him at the hands of the Crusader, and Odin had to revive his dead body.
http://www.marveldirectory.com/individuals/c/crusader.htm
This would not happen to Pitt, in actuality Pitt would have laughed at such a strike and in the next instant the Crusader would have died.
Thor would not survive a hand to hand encounter with Pitt in a non CIS battle. Could Pit sever Thors arms at the wrists? Hell yea! No hands, no Mjolnir.
Would Thor survive a few slashes to the face like the one that he scored on the Hulk? Hell no!
Colossus, Wonderman, Hercules, Thing, Ironman, Namor, She Hulk, Thor, Wonder Woman, Orion, Ulik, Terrax, Super Skrull, Sasquatch, Aquaman, Vargas, Firelord, Captain Curtis... etc...etc... the list goes on, they would all die, if they mixed it up with Pitt.
Like I said imagine Wolverine with class 100 str. indestructible muscle fibers, psychic powers, the ability to lock onto his his prey, and feed off of their agressisons, and is stimulated by pain to become an even greater combattant. This means that this guy wouldn't be able to be put down, and even if he was, it wouldn't be for long.
Pitt was engineered to be the perfect weapon, his purpose was to infiltrate planets and destroy all sentient life on said planet, all by himself. I've seen the aliens that he wiped out and if you were to throw any of these guys into the Dynasty Warrior type scene that Pitt was in, they would be swallowed. Superman as the only exception to the rule, and only because of his natural body armor.
If you fight a guy that can take anything you dish out, but you are hurt by everything he dishes out, it is evident who the victor will eventually be. Thor has no healing factor... this would become a battle of attrition, and Pitt would heal while Thor would not.