Originally posted by Elite Hunter
Anakin might win a strict saber duel vs the 2. But would definitely fall in an all out fight.
Actually, Anakin isn't really that good in sabers to win against both Malak and Traya. Remember that he only took down Dooku with Sidious' goading, and Traya can use telekinetic lightsaber combat.
Originally posted by caedusrulesall
Actually, Anakin isn't really that good in sabers to win against both Malak and Traya. Remember that he only took down Dooku with Sidious' goading, and Traya can use telekinetic lightsaber combat.
Actually sidious's goading had not to much affect on the duel. And the novel makes it clear that Dooku even realizes ( one on one btw) that Anakin is holding back yet still beating him. Anakin does stand a fairly good shot in a saber duel though if Traya is allowed her 3 tk lightsabers it can throw him off but he certainly could take either of these two one on one in a saber contest.
The novel also depicts an entirely different fight than that which we see in the movie, so it's irrelevant.
In a saber duel, Anakin dies, although he'd certainly put up a good fight. Fending off the ridiculously massive Malak - who has superior strength and reach, and also familiarity with his style - while having Traya's disembodied lightsabers hacking at his back? He's going down.
In a Force battle, Anakin gets raped. No further elaboration necessary.
In an all-out battle... see the above.
Originally posted by Faunus
The novel also depicts an entirely different fight than that which we see in the movie, so it's irrelevant.
No, it's not. Only because the novel describes the fight differently what happens in the movie is actually NOT relevant? That's just plain stupid. I would consider what is seen in the movie a more powerful source than what we read in the novel. The novel contradicting the movie, THAT is just plain stupid, not viceversa.
Originally posted by 0°Mandalore°0Which is what I said, moron. And knowing that, you're previous point is moot.
No, it's not. Only because the novel describes the fight differently what happens in the movie is actually NOT relevant? That's just plain stupid. I would consider what is seen in the movie a more powerful source than what we read in the novel. The novel contradicting the movie, THAT is just plain stupid, not viceversa.
Originally posted by Faunus
Which is what I said, moron. And knowing that, you're previous point is moot.
If you actually did, just make your point a bit clearer, please. And I was looking forward to a civilized debate, not to one filled with insults and offenses (which this would apparently be).
So keep that in mind becuase if you do it again, you'll be reported. And I wouldn't like that because I think I would rather enjoy debating with you.
Originally posted by 0°Mandalore°0He is not a newb... He is one of the most intelligent debaters here honestly and has been here for quite some time, just that he has not gotten on in a while.
So keep that in mind becuase if you do it again, you'll be reported, which would indeed be a shame considering you're a newbie.
Anyways back to the fight, in a strict saber duel, he can beat each of them individually but with malak and kreia together, he goes down pretty badly.
And as faunus said, anakin gets tooled in an all out fight considering kreia and malaks force strength.
Originally posted by Faunus
The novel also depicts an entirely different fight than that which we see in the movie, so it's irrelevant.
I was under the impression because that since it is only describing the thoughts( in this particular passage anyway) and is not contradicting a scene in the movie that it is canon.
Anakin will most likely lose the saber conflict. Although, I do not consider Traya'a ability with the blade very impressive, her telekinetic lightsaber ability will come in handy against him.
Anakin will not be able to fend off Malak's aggressive, powerful blows while dealing with Traya's three or more lightsabers.
Originally posted by 0°Mandalore°0My mistake; I was tired.
If you actually did, just make your point a bit clearer, please. And I was looking forward to a civilized debate, not to one filled with insults and offenses (which this would apparently be).So keep that in mind becuase if you do it again, you'll be reported. And I wouldn't like that because I think I would rather enjoy debating with you.
And FYI; the mods don't really respond to reports until they've gotten fifty of them.