ROTS obi wan vs ROTS cin drallig

who wins

Obi-Wan, though I doubt it would be a walk in the park.

Agreed. Cin Drallig was one of the best swordsman of his time, but against obi wan, master of soresu, i don't think he would win.

Agreed.

This Drallig character is said to be an excellent swordsman, but I doubt that he can match Kenobi in the force.

Nor does he have Kenobi's experience.

Originally posted by Light_Sith
Agreed.

This Drallig character is said to be an excellent swordsman, but I doubt that he can match Kenobi in the force.

Nor does he have Kenobi's experience.

Actually I believe Drallig might have the edge experience wise since I recall correctly he became the battle master around the time of TPM. Though I think Obiwan would win the fight it will be a difficult one imo.

Originally posted by Elite Hunter
Actually I believe Drallig might have the edge experience wise since I recall correctly he became the battle master around the time of TPM. Though I think Obiwan would win the fight it will be a difficult one imo.

The battlemaster title has always been a bit confusing (to me at least).

It would make sense for these guys to have top-notch experience so I suppose your point is valid.

Still, Kenobi has a pretty good resume with his General status in the Clone Wars and his fights against the Sith.

Out of curiosity, what Form did this battlemaster prefer?

he specialized in all forms except vaapad.

Originally posted by skywalker833
he specialized in all forms except vaapad.

Dooku was once a "battlemaster" and he was said to have a "working knowledge" of most other forms.

I take it that this Drallig guy did not actually "Master" all Forms (save Vaapad of course).

Originally posted by Light_Sith
Dooku was once a "battlemaster" and he was said to have a "working knowledge" of most other forms.

Ah, Dooku was never the battlemaster of the jedi order. Though he was very knowledgeable and skilled in most forms of saber combat and would be very qualified for the position. Prior to TPM it was most likely Anoon Bondara and the same year when he died is when Cin Drallig filled the position till his death.

Originally posted by Elite Hunter
Ah, Dooku was never the battlemaster of the jedi order(Though he was very knowledgeable and skilled in most forms of saber combat) . Prior to TPM it was most likely Anoon Bondara and the same year when he died is when Cin Drallig filled the position till his death.

Well, he certainly sounds like an interesting character.

yeah, too bad anakin pwned him...

Originally posted by skywalker833
yeah, too bad anakin pwned him...

With one arm none the less.

lol, yeah, that is what it looked like from the recordings.

Pity we did not see this properly on Screen.

Instead, we got Vader killing children 😠

WTF with Anakin killing him with ease. I mean, the BATTLEMASTER is supposed to be one of the most powerful Jedi in the Order. Anakin beating the guy with one hand just... no.

Originally posted by Elite Hunter
Actually I believe Drallig might have the edge experience wise since I recall correctly he became the battle master around the time of TPM. Though I think Obiwan would win the fight it will be a difficult one imo.

And, we don't know the circumstances behind the Cin and Vader fight, but I personally hope that material gets released saying that Cin was wounded by a blaster shot or something and that's why he died so quickly.

Yeah, I cannot possibly see how anakin would have beaten him so easily.

Cin Drallig even trained him and obi wan in lightsaber combat.

So does everyone agree that obi1 wins, considering no one has posted for a while?

Hello?