AS Superman-Sodam Yat vs WM Thor-Silver Sufer

Well who takes it?

Team 2.

Team probably since Silver Sufer beats Superman, and then its 2 vs 1. Sodam Yat wont be able to beat them

Sufer can beat All-Star Supes?

I thought AS Supes would've been able to beat either of team 2. Although not easily, and not at the same time.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Sufer can beat All-Star Supes?

Wait a minute I though that Silver surfer was able to take away Solar Energy from living things or animals?

Originally posted by Galan007
Based on feats, yeah.

team 1

Originally posted by vlaaad12345
Based on feats a weakened allstar punched a planet into a different dimension...call me crazy but I see surfer not taking that kinda physical punishment very well.

It's not like he struck it, and *poof* it was in another realm. srsly

I still don't think Surfer can take AS Supes.

Couldn't Surfer feasibly just pump AS Superman with a ridiculous amount more of solar radiation, causing his cells to bloat even further and explode?

Team 2

Originally posted by MightyEInherjar
Couldn't Surfer feasibly just pump AS Superman with a ridiculous amount more of solar radiation, causing his cells to bloat even further and explode?

I don't think it's a stretch to say that Surfer wouldn't have time to do that.

I vote Team 1.

Originally posted by MightyEInherjar
Couldn't Surfer feasibly just pump AS Superman with a ridiculous amount more of solar radiation, causing his cells to bloat even further and explode?

Originally posted by Galan007
That, or just emit red Sun radiation.

IMO this is only possible if AS Supes if fighting Thor, because if Supes targets SS, SS won't have time to perform this type of attack.

Originally posted by Unnatural-POWER
IMO this is only possible if AS Supes if fighting Thor, because if Supes targets SS, SS won't have time to perform this type of attack.

Listen,
A/S is one of my favorites, but he hardly has sufficient feats to put him in the same bracket as such a versatile opponent -- let alone beat him.

Originally posted by Galan007
And when Surfer goes intangible just before A/S reaches him? ermm

Listen,
A/S is one of my favorites, but he hardly has sufficient feats to put him in the same bracket as such a versatile opponent -- let alone beat him.

Admittedly, i was kinda thinking of regular Supes + AS Supes when i wrote that.
Based on feats then AS Supes hasn't fought someone with Surfers powerset, so no conclusion can be made that doesn't have some form of speculation to it.

Is what i wrote THAT unfathomable though?

Originally posted by Unnatural-POWER
Admittedly, i was kinda thinking of regular Supes + AS Supes when i wrote that.
Based on feats then AS Supes hasn't fought someone with Surfers powerset, so no conclusion can be made that doesn't have some form of speculation to it.

Is what i wrote THAT unfathomable though?

Now don't get me wrong,
A/S has some crazy feats -- but to date, he hasn't the feats to put him on Surfer's level, imo.

but who cares about feats? It's just been a superb story... Every single issue is excellent.

Originally posted by Galan007
Not at all.

Now don't get me wrong,
A/S has some crazy feats -- but to date, he hasn't the feats to put him on Surfer's level, imo.

but who cares about feats? It's just been a superb story... Every single issue is excellent.

That's fair 🙂

I agree it's superb, one of my favourites actually. Great taste pal thumbsup