Thor vs Superman

Started by WrathfulDwarf453 pages

Originally posted by llagrok
What the hell?

The Hulk jumped him from BEHIND! How was Thor supposed to defend against that?

You proven my point Illagrok.

If Thor CAN react agaisnt a speedblitz....then how did The Hulk jumped him from behind?

Hulk posess NO speed whatsoever...

Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
You proven my point Illagrok.

If Thor CAN react agaisnt a speedblitz....then how did The Hulk jumped him from behind?

Hulk posess NO speed whatsoever...

Well, Thor was carrying him and then suddenly the Hulk attacked.

Originally posted by Larceny
I don't believe it does.

Again, as I've pointed out, Kal is faster. However it's not enough so to make an actual difference in battle. You can ignore that fact that Thor's dealt with numerous top tiers that have in fact used speed in battle. You can ignore the fact that at one point Thor's even humiliated Hermes, and has in fact shown reflexes to deal with FLT projectiles. I'll go the logical route, Thor's capable of dealing with Kal's speed.

Thor hardly has dealt with anyone using their speed to speedblitz him. When they did it worked everytime against him.

Do you now see the faultiness of your reasoning? Just because someone was shown to do X doesn't mean that they are doing it in a particular fight. For example, WW have FTL reflexes but Slade hit her. Does Slade move faster than light? What about about Grundy, etc?


What's funny is Mjolnir is faster than Kal, and Thor easily reacts to it all the time.

http://i38.photobucket.com/albums/e101/Soujaboy/Thor%20Feats/IWhomTheGodsWouldDestroy-35.jpg
http://i38.photobucket.com/albums/e101/Soujaboy/Thor%20Feats/IWhomTheGodsWouldDestroy-36.jpg

You must know that it takes Thor much time to build up
enough speed to hurl the hammer faster than light. Superman would have koed him in the first millisecond.

Oh and BTW, Thor's made sonic Booms with combat speed.

http://i38.photobucket.com/albums/e101/Soujaboy/Thor%20Feats/Thorspeed.jpg

You and all the other Thor fans are extremely funny and common. You guys always seem to misinterpret Thor scans. The scan says "with Force" and not "with enough speed". The author cleary was showing that the blow made a loud sound because of the force and not the speed. And sonic speed is nowhere near comparable light speed. Superman sees high calibur bullets (sonic speed) as in still motion.

What's left to prove? He's used the Odin Power to amplify his physical attributes.

He'll be able to use it. I believe you should be more worried about proving Superman's going to start the battle out with a speedblitz, something I don't believe he's ever done. Assuming we're using forum rules, he would be fighting in character.

You also confused the fighting in character rule. Superman has speedblitz people before. Just because he hasn't did it in the very beginning (he has several times though, when he was mad) doesn't mean he won't do it. Otherwise, Thor won't Godblast, BFR, etc. in the beginning either, Blackbolt won't scream in the beginning, and many others won't do their top powers in the beginning either. My friend, you forgot the whole point of this forum (and comic debating). The point is to show that based solely off of powerset who will win.

Now Superman can defeat the Destroyer?
ABC logic fails. If not then I can prove that Superman>Thor>Superman>Thor>...
which is nonsense.

If you wanna feats War you won't win. I'm not bringing various, ambiguous speed feats. I'm coming armed with feats displaying Thor warping the universe, busting Celestial armor, nearly killing Galactus, etc.
I've seen them all (I have access to nearly every best thing Thor has done). And you know what? More than half of these feats are misinterpreted, invalid, or really weak.

I'm not. However I believe that accusation does fit you quite well.

Unfortunately for your argument, this isn't DC comics. This wont be a physical battle, and even if it were Thor would likely win. He'd simply amplify his physical attributes beyond those of Kal's and put em to work.

Again this thread is about classic Thor and not current (look at the OP). If you want to argue current Thor you must do it in another thread.

Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
You proven my point Illagrok.

If Thor CAN react agaisnt a speedblitz....then how did The Hulk jumped him from behind?

Hulk posess NO speed whatsoever...

I see the point your making but its still not exactly fair.

Originally posted by h1a8
You and all the other Thor fans are extremely funny and common. You guys always seem to misinterpret Thor scans. The scan says "with Force" and not "with enough speed". The author cleary was showing that the blow made a loud sound because of the force and not the speed. And sonic speed is nowhere near comparable light speed. Superman sees high calibur bullets (sonic speed) as in still motion.

This is just hilarious.

Thor has virtually no speed feats, and is usually portrayed as a powerful, but not quick warrior who resorts to strength rather than nimbleness to win.

Superman has time and again demonstrated incredible feats of speed, some that rival the speedster Flash.

Yet, people are actually trying to argue that Thor can deal with Superman's speed based on the most speculative arguments. It's simply ridiculous.

Originally posted by llagrok
This is just hilarious.

Actually you are hilarious. You are becoming more and more of a Fanboy the more this topic progresses. You haven't even posted anything that is actually memoriable to think that thor has a chance. He posted a prefectly good reason, yet you call him Hilarious??? LMAO!

So thor totally hasnt reacted to the speed of his own hammer before.

Originally posted by h1a8
Thor hardly has dealt with anyone using their speed to speedblitz him. When they did it worked everytime against him.

Do you now see the faultiness of your reasoning? Just because someone was shown to do X doesn't mean that they are doing it in a particular fight. For example, WW have FTL reflexes but Slade hit her. Does Slade move faster than light? What about about Grundy, etc?
You must know that it takes Thor much time to build up
enough speed to hurl the hammer faster than light. Superman would have koed him in the first millisecond.
You and all the other Thor fans are extremely funny and common. You guys always seem to misinterpret Thor scans. The scan says "with Force" and not "with enough speed". The author cleary was showing that the blow made a loud sound because of the force and not the speed. And sonic speed is nowhere near comparable light speed. Superman sees high calibur bullets (sonic speed) as in still motion.
You also confused the fighting in character rule. Superman has speedblitz people before. Just because he hasn't did it in the very beginning (he has several times though, when he was mad) doesn't mean he won't do it. Otherwise, Thor won't Godblast, BFR, etc. in the beginning either, Blackbolt won't scream in the beginning, and many others won't do their top powers in the beginning either. My friend, you forgot the whole point of this forum (and comic debating). The point is to show that based solely off of powerset who will win.
ABC logic fails. If not then I can prove that Superman>Thor>Superman>Thor>...
which is nonsense.
I've seen them all (I have access to nearly every best thing Thor has done). And you know what? More than half of these feats are misinterpreted, invalid, or really weak.
Again this thread is about classic Thor and not current (look at the OP). If you want to argue current Thor you must do it in another thread.

Thanks. You saved me some typing and got to the point of these just fine.

Thor hasn't dealt with the speedblitz/strength combo of Superman. The hammer throw as a feat is hilarious...especially considering Mjolnirs properties...

Hell, he had trouble with superskrull using invisibility, and things strength..two things Superman could use to superior levels with ease.

Originally posted by vlaaad12345
So thor totally hasnt reacted to the speed of his own hammer before.
his own hammer is mystically attuned to him

so I guess Thor can now handle Flash-level speed, since Superman is comparable to Flash's speed

Originally posted by Avlon
Thanks. You saved me some typing and got to the point of these just fine.

Thor hasn't dealt with the speedblitz/strength combo of Superman. The hammer throw as a feat is hilarious...especially considering Mjolnirs properties...

Hell, he had trouble with superskrull using invisibility, and things strength..two things Superman could use to superior levels with ease.

How old is that scan?

Originally posted by Mindset
How old is that scan?

As old as some of the feats that are still clung to by Thors fans. 🙂

Originally posted by Master-Borg
his own hammer is mystically attuned to him

so I guess Thor can now handle Flash-level speed, since Superman is comparable to Flash's speed

Superman isn't THAT fast compared to Flash.

Has anyone got an actual scan of him responding to Superman level speed?

Originally posted by Ricardo Potter
Superman isn't THAT fast compared to Flash.

Has anyone got an actual scan of him responding to Superman level speed?

Superman is slower than Flash...but his speed is comparable

Thor cannot deal with such speed

Hasn't Flash moved fast enough so Superman couldn't see him?

Does Thor have ANY speed feats from the last 10 years?

k guys, this is CURRENT THOR, the one who busted the dread destroyer
with the same hammer throw that felled superman in the "infamous fight". though superman triumphed, it wasn't a flawless victory.

if regular thor can hit superman, current can and that will be all she wrote.

and thats not tacking into account the additional powers of thor the writers of the crossover "forgot" + the new ones of his father.

Why last 10 years? It all should count should it not?

Originally posted by psycho gundam
k guys, this is CURRENT THOR, the one who busted the dread destroyer

is current thor any faster than classic thor?

remember, this is a kMC fight, not a comic fight where charcters dont use all their abilities

Originally posted by Ricardo Potter
Why last 10 years? It all should count should it not?
Im not discounting his other feats...just would like to see some of Thor's more recent speed feats

I mean, if he can handle Superman's speed, he must have a few speed feats, right?