Originally posted by Peach
Um, I still have no idea what you're talking about. I've never said anything about the destruction of any forums, either. There are forums I dislike, yes, but that doesn't mean I want them to go away ermm
You totally don't recall when you were supporting the notion of getting rid of the versus forums?
Originally posted by Peach
And I never said I invalidated anything you said, but that what you said makes no ****ing sense.
Captain Obvious: IT doesn't make sense when you don't understand what the person is saying.
You invalidated one of YOUR arguments when you tried to show evidence that invalidated another one of YOUR arguments.
"I'm not trying to say that it would instantly fail like all the other ones that have instantly failed, but all the other times a new forum was begged for it instantly failed."
Originally posted by Peach
And really, I have no idea what you are babbling about, anyway. I never said KMC was an elitist clique. What I am trying to get across is that just because something is popular does not necessarily mean there will be enough interest
Because popular things aren't interesting...
Originally posted by Peach
here on this specific corner of the internet to keep a forum HERE going. We have sections here that are immensely popular and that you can find tons of discussion about on other forums but do not do so well here. Just as we have sections here that are huge that don't do well on other forums.
Got proof of this last part? You know the whole concept of KMC having exclusive forums?
Originally posted by Peach
It's simply a quirk as to how the internet can work.
Riiight... You related to Al Gore?
Originally posted by Peach
And in all honesty, I'd think that if people were interested in discussing something, they'd be seeking out forums/threads to discuss it in. Such threads ARE available on KMC,
AS SMurph already said, a single thread might become complicated to try and follow discussion in when anything you want to say about a topic with a vast array of subjects is all crammed into one.
"Oh the other day I was talking about phaser modulation, now I have to sift through pages of tribble talk to find it"
And you claim to know how the internet works.
Originally posted by Peach
but as has been pointed out by other people in here already, they are not terribly active threads.[b/]
THREADS... These people obviously know how the internet works. Obfuscation of ability to discuss things related to a fandom really does wonders to sustain interest in the THREAD... or you know not, people don't like being confused.
Originally posted by Peach
[B]I am wondering where you got "I wouldn't use it so it shouldn't exist" from anything I've said.
Your arguing against the idea coupled with statments about how you wouldn't use it OBVIOUSLY...
Originally posted by Peach
It really is a fact that most people who vote for the creation of a forum - people who DO say they are interested - then go on to never post in there.
And you're arguing against it and one of your arguments is that you personally would not use it.
Originally posted by Peach
It's been seen on here a number of times. Thus someone like me, who isn't interested, saying yes would be simply nothing but false support. I won't say no - but I won't say yes either.
But you will argue against it, and you'll try and stem support for the idea... that's tatamount to saying no without saying the word no itself.
"Its a bad idea"
"Don't say no."
"I didn't, I'm just sayuing its a bad idea."
So basically ... you're trolling again. trying to start fights with the supporters by attacking their ideas, but you're not ACTUALLY opposed to the idea, even though you're arguing with the supporters against it?
Originally posted by Peach
I honestly have no idea why you're jumping all over me for expressing an opinion based on something I've seen happen many times on here.
Trolls get attacked... its probably why they troll.
Originally posted by Peach
If people want to discuss Star Trek then go for it. It doesn't bother me. I'm just extending a...cautious warning,
A rather vocal warning you mean.
Originally posted by Peach
I suppose, based on how things have gone down on KMC in the past (multiple times) and how "popularity amongst the entire fanbase" doesn't always equate to "huge amount of interest in discussion on KMC".
So you attack the idea, argue with the supporters but aren't opposed to the idea?
Doesn't that sound fishy to you?
Originally posted by Peach
I wonder what bias that could be because, unless my memory has completely and totally fried, Ush does like Star Trek.
Uh huh... pull the other one. He clearly stated that its not worth while... but star wars apparently is...
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/search.php?action=showresults&q=forumid%3A6+userid%3A8
Lore check on my name before you say word one about my "bias".
Originally posted by General Kaliero
Dude, I think you're missing an important point here. Peach isn't saying that a Star Trek forum would be BAD. She's not AGAINST it. She's saying that based on previous evidence, it's not a sure thing that such a forum would do well here, specifically, on KMC.
That'd be credible if
a.) You weren't her pet.
b.) What you said didn't contradict her statements and actions.