Originally posted by skywalker833
I don't think bane would win that easily. Luke had already made some amazing force feats, and just defeated the greatest sith lord in saber combat to become a jedi master.
Indeed? Sidious pwned him when they fought evenly, and he required the assistance of the entire light side of the force aka Leia's battle meditation to overcome him later on.
You know why I so absolutely hate Luke? Because he's the ultimate good guy... he's the friggin' avatar of light, with no sense of humor or any sort of personality quirks. He's just... good, and all-powerful. He's the counterpart to Sidious; but evil people are more interesting 😈 . So yeah...
But, unfortunately, Luke at his peak- he's close to his peak in JA, but he's not NJO level yet- would defeat ALMOST everyone in the Star Wars universe.
In the force, I'd personally have to give this to Luke. I mean... Luke's displays incredible force powers, capable of cutting off the strongest dark side user in history from the force- albeit with help- and I see no doubt that he would do the same to Bane. Luke has achieved his father's potential in the force, and thus, it would be logical that he can overpower Bane.
In sabers... well, it'd be very close, but ultimately it can go either way. Both were extremely good saber fighters, and masters of Djem So, but it's possible that Bane might have a slight edge. Maybe, but not necessarily; so, all in all, I'd call it a tie with a slight edge to Bane.
All in all, Luke would beat Bane after a particularly tough and vicious fight.
ok you dont know much. he didn't cut the most powerful one from the force. Trapped and alone vs 5 jedis, sideous's faulty and overpowered body was decaying and getting old. When he died of old age and getting constantly pounded on by the 5 jedis, he entered the body of one of the jedis, and the jedi's will was strong enough to contain him inside his body, sacrificing himself in the process. When the jedi died, so did sideous. Luke did pretty much nothing to kill sideous.
Bane would take it in sabers. he has orbalisks, and has killed the master of djem so of his era. Bane would kick him with sabers.
I haven't seen very much forcewise from luke at this point. I have read dark empire, and although he looks his best, kinda darksidey, in this comic book, he shows very little force power. I do understand that this is a while after, but he still isn't that powerful.
Bane however has done alot. he excercised ultra powerful sith lightning, and extreme cunning.
Originally posted by Lord Knightfa11
ok you dont know much. he didn't cut the most powerful one from the force. Trapped and alone vs 5 jedis, sideous's faulty and overpowered body was decaying and getting old. When he died of old age and getting constantly pounded on by the 5 jedis, he entered the body of one of the jedis, and the jedi's will was strong enough to contain him inside his body, sacrificing himself in the process. When the jedi died, so did sideous. Luke did pretty much nothing to kill sideous.
You don't know much. In DE, Luke,Leia, and the unborn Anakin Solo did cut him off from the force and he lost control of his force storm and then it destroyed the eclipse and Sidious's clone body.
You are thinking of his final death In Empire's End.
Originally posted by Lord Knightfa11
Sabers=bane (orbalisks, all sorts of awesome crap like killing that noob guy who was the master swordsman)
Force=luke
All out=bane (bane doesnt have to do much to get luke, and luke isnt that powerful by now. luke also hasn't shown lighting, the ability that could take apart the orbalisks. luke would have to get a headshot, and luke's lightsaber form isn't known for its accuracy)Im not a bane fanboy, this is just my opinion.