Ganthet vs Thanos

Originally posted by fangirl101
if he was depowered, then how was he able to come back from the dead. that was an instinctual thing. he wasn't able to summon the magic. depowered would mean he had no powers. he still had his powers at the end of the story as he talked about the story.

"No magic for imp!" "Return magic to imp!" "Return home Mxyzplitlk!"

Also, he couldn't destroy him because:
"You might have been quick enough to catch him unawares, but you can never take away his essence. Nor can you completely beat down any of us who exist beyond our wits."

I see it the same as when Black Alice took away Spectre's power.

I know you won't... but that's to be expected.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist You just said she cut him off from his magic. Obviously he was depowered."No magic for imp!" "Return magic to imp!" "Return home Mxyzplitlk!"Also, he couldn't destroy him because:"You might have been quick enough to catch him unawares, but you can never take away his essence. Nor can you completely beat down any of us who exist beyond our wits."I see it the same as when Black Alice took away Spectre's power.I know you won't... but that's to be expected.

Originally posted by iceman24567
We can only guess why that happened though the kid does absorb solar energy so maybe the energy released was comparable on some level? Just a guess anyways. Just saying the energy in a Guardian is up there maybe not what people are saying because their feats don't support the statements made.

being able to push someone into the bleed with pure force says alot. the guardian was also so strong, that superboy prime couldn't break his grip.

Originally posted by Avlon
Really? So I guess ODIN didn't say that he taps into an external force here.

Once again, why would a guardian have to tap into an entire battery? Their on panel description says they are comparable to a battery. It may be subjective, but in no way does that hinder them in this fight.

I guess you completely missed the part where I say even if it is external that is power he uses, and no Guardian has used the entire Power Battery, nor have they shown power equal to or even close to someone using the full battery.

You ignore words that make you posts useless. 😉

Again, post proof of a Guardians power equal or close to someone using the full battery or stop posting here because anything you say is unimportant dribble. 🙂

Originally posted by Mindset
I guess you completely missed the part where I say even if it is external that is power he uses, and no Guardian has used the entire Power Battery, nor have they shown power equal to or even close to someone using the full battery.

I guess you missed both what's been stated on panel, the feats that have been posted, and how nobody has claimed that a Guardian needs to match an entire Oan battery to win. 🙂

Originally posted by Mindset
You ignore words that make you posts useless. 😉

Nope. You just make no sense and have a lack of reading comprehension. Then again, you debated that GR will beat DD. That alone says enough about you.

Originally posted by Mindset
Again, post proof of a Guardians power equal or close to someone using the full battery or stop posting here because anything you say is unimportant dribble. 🙂

Yes. Because you've shown proof of? That's right...nada. Just what we need. Another useless poster. 😆

I like how you ignored the Odin scan. 😉

Originally posted by Avlon
I guess you missed both what's been stated on panel, the feats that have been posted, and how nobody has claimed that a Guardian needs to match an entire Oan battery to win. 🙂

Nope. You just make no sense and have a lack of reading comprehension. Then again, you debated that GR will beat DD. That alone says enough about you.

Yes. Because you've shown proof of? That's right...nada. Just what we need. Another useless poster. 😆

I like how you ignored the Odin scan. 😉

You are rather dense.

When did I claim Ganthet needed to match the strength of the Oan battery to beat Thanos, in an earlier post you even tried to say I was implying that, then I went on to tell you that I wasn't, I was just correcting the false claims on a Guardians power.

Lack of reading comprehension, really, what may I ask didn't I understand? You haven't said anything to prove that Ganthet is as powerful as the battery, which is what I've been saying is wrong.

Yes, bring in what happens in another thread, which is irrelevant, and try to make the claim that I don't know what I'm talking about here when in fact I doubt you even read Green Lantern comics. Not too mention that you never gave a reason how DD beats GR and I said that GR can't beat DD with punches and kicks, but could possibly do it with his Penance Stare, and I even went on to say I'll have to read up some more to make sure I'm right...yea you really got me there Avlon.

What do you want me to show proof of? That Ganthet is not equal to the battery, you want me to prove the negative?

Yea I ignored the Odin pic, that's why it was the first thing I addressed in my post...you're a joke.

Originally posted by Cartesian Doubt
I'm afraid to say that i did actually read the story, and I'm sure I killed a part of my soul in doing so. There is no ref to Zatanna thingy girl de-powering Myx.

Originally posted by fangirl101
she did not. she used a spell to sap his will from being able to summon his magic. basically he was still omnipotent, but had no way to summon up any magic. he wasn't depowered as evident that when superman prime had "killed" mxy, he just woke back up and healed himself.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
You just said she cut him off from his magic. Obviously he was depowered.

"No magic for imp!" "Return magic to imp!" "Return home Mxyzplitlk!"

Also, he couldn't destroy him because:
"You might have been quick enough to catch him unawares, but you can never take away his essence. Nor can you completely beat down any of us who exist beyond our wits."

I see it the same as when Black Alice took away Spectre's power.

I know you won't... but that's to be expected.

Originally posted by fangirl101
being able to push someone into the bleed with pure force says alot. the guardian was also so strong, that superboy prime couldn't break his grip.

Originally posted by Mindset
You are rather dense.

Mindless gibberish.

Originally posted by Mindset
When did I claim Ganthet needed to match the strength of the Oan battery to beat Thanos, in an earlier post you even tried to say I was implying that, then I went on to tell you that I wasn't, I was just correcting the false claims on a Guardians power.

Correcting with what? Did you bring some sort of proof to the thread?
Stating that you have a differing opinion is fine. Correcting would require proof...which you don't have.

Originally posted by Mindset
Lack of reading comprehension, really, I what may I ask didn't I understand? You haven't said anything to prove that Ganthet is as powerful as the battery, which is what I've been saying is wrong.

That's because I nor anyone has claimed that he would need that type of power to battle Thanos..duh...

Originally posted by Mindset
Yes, bring in what happens in another thread, which is irrelevant, and try to make the claim that I don't know what I'm talking about here when in fact I doubt you even read Green Lantern comics. Not too mention that you never gave a reason how DD beats GR and I said that GR can't beat DD with punches and kicks, but could possibly do it with his Penance Stare, and I even went on to say I'll have to read up some more to make sure I'm right...yea you really got me there Avlon.

You made excuses in that thread because you got caught with your pants down. Now you make an unsupported claim that I don't read GL comics.

Laughable.

Originally posted by Mindset
What do you want me to show proof of? That Ganthet is not equal to the battery, you want me to prove the negative?

If you are claiming that he isn't as powerful as an Oan battery (not that it really matters..but hey...you wanted to "correct" people) then show proof.

My theory is simple. They tap into the power the same way Odin can tap into the odinforce.

I don't know why you even brought up that they don't have parallax or Ion feats....why the hell would they have to?

Originally posted by Mindset
Yea I ignored the Odin pic, that's why it was the first thing I addressed in my post...you're a joke.

Hmm...

Originally posted by Mindset
Yes, Odin and the Odinforce and Guardians and the central power battery share so much in common. 😐 Odinforce is a part of Odin,

Originally posted by Mindset
I'd be happy for you to prove me wrong Avlon.

🙂

Originally posted by Avlon
And you are a moron. I'll stick with dense.

Correcting with what? Did you bring some sort of proof to the thread?
Stating that you have a differing opinion is fine. Correcting would require proof...which you don't have.

That's because I nor anyone has claimed that he would need that type of power to battle Thanos..duh...

You made excuses in that thread because you got caught with your pants down. Now you make an unsupported claim that I don't read GL comics.

Laughable.

If you are claiming that he isn't as powerful as an Oan battery (not that it really matters..but hey...you wanted to "correct" people) then show proof.

My theory is simple. They tap into the power the same way Odin can tap into the odinforce.

I don't know why you even brought up that they don't have parallax or Ion feats....why the hell would they have to?

Hmm...

🙂

*sigh*

I'll make this simple for you Avlon.

Guardians are not as strong as the battery until they have proven themselves to be.

I never said Guardians could not tap into the battery, it would make sense that they could use the entire battery when Kyle and Hal could, but CIS was not taken away so Ganthet will not do that.

I never said Ganthet would need to be as strong as the battery to beat Thanos.

Caught with my pants down in GR vs. DD thread, no, could I be wrong in that GR could beat DD, yes, but did you prove anything...no.

Originally posted by Mindset
*sigh*

I'll make this simple for you Avlon.

Guardians are not as strong as the battery until they have proven themselves to be.

I never said Guardians could not tap into the battery, it would make sense that they could use the entire battery when Kyle and Hal could, but CIS was not taken away so Ganthet will not do that.

I never said Ganthet would need to be as strong as the battery to beat Thanos.

Caught with my pants down in GR vs. DD thread, no, could I be wrong in that GR could beat DD, yes, but did you prove anything...no.

I will break it down Barney style.

I was simply correcting what you stated. That Odinforce comes from Odin. He's a high level being that taps into it...he doesn't use it all at once.

The Guardians power being so great that each is like a living power battery doesn't automatically state that they are equal to Parallax or Ion. They are high level beings that tap into an unlimited source. That's still damn powerful.

You stated complete fallacy in that thread. I corrected it. No biggie though. We can leave that one alone.

Originally posted by Avlon
I will break it down Barney style.

I was simply correcting what you stated. That Odinforce comes from Odin. He's a high level being that taps into it...he doesn't use it all at once.

The Guardians power being so great that each is like a living power battery doesn't automatically state that they are equal to Parallax or Ion. They are high level beings that tap into an unlimited source. That's still damn powerful.

You stated complete fallacy in that thread. I corrected it. No biggie though. We can leave that one alone.

It's true that I said the Odinforce came from Odin, I also said whether it was external or not doesn't matter because it is power he uses, the Guardian's do not use the entire battery, nor have they ever shown to be as strong as the battery.

People were suggesting that the Guardians were as strong as the battery, if they were they'd be as strong as someone who is using the entirety of the battery, whether they have the power to use the entire battery or not doesn't matter, even I think they can, but it doesn't matter because they wont.

I was never saying the Guardians weren't powerful, they just are not as powerful as people are claiming, unless you want to take statements over actual feats.

Originally posted by Mindset
It's true that I said the Odinforce came from Odin, I also said whether it was external or not doesn't matter because it is power he uses, the Guardian's do not use the entire battery, nor have they ever shown to be as strong as the battery.

People were suggesting that the Guardians were as strong as the battery, if they were they'd be as strong as someone who is using the entirety of the battery, whether they have the power to use the entire battery or not doesn't matter, even I think they can, but it doesn't matter because they wont.

I was never saying the Guardians weren't powerful, they just are not as powerful as people are claiming, unless you want to take statements over actual feats.

Who prevails?

Originally posted by Mindset
It's true that I said the Odinforce came from Odin, I also said whether it was external or not doesn't matter because it is power he uses, the Guardian's do not use the entire battery, nor have they ever shown to be as strong as the battery.

I don't think either Odin nor Ganthet would need to tap into their whole power source to win this battle. Showing Ganthet to be as powerful as an entire battery is irrelevant in all seriousness.

Originally posted by Mindset
People were suggesting that the Guardians were as strong as the battery, if they were they'd be as strong as someone who is using the entirety of the battery, whether they have the power to use the entire battery or not doesn't matter, even I think they can, but it doesn't matter because they wont.

I don't think that they are as strong as the entire battery at once either. Even if they were, it would be hard to verify since they (Guardians) don't usually involve themselves in battle.

Originally posted by Mindset
I was never saying the Guardians weren't powerful, they just are not as powerful as people are claiming, unless you want to take statements over actual feats.

I simply brought up the statement that was presented on panel by DC. Even in the original statement I don't think that they meant that they are exactly = to a battery.

Originally posted by Avlon
I don't think either Odin nor Ganthet would need to tap into their whole power source to win this battle. Showing Ganthet to be as powerful as an entire battery is irrelevant in all seriousness.

I don't think that they are as strong as the entire battery at once either. Even if they were, it would be hard to verify since they (Guardians) don't usually involve themselves in battle.

I simply brought up the statement that was presented on panel by DC. Even in the original statement I don't think that they meant that they are exactly = to a battery.

I'm not sure if you have been getting this, but I was never arguing the Ganthet needed to tap into the entire power the battery holds to beat Thanos, I was never even talking about the fight between the two. I was correcting people in saying that Ganthet = The Battery.

Ganthet.

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Ganthet.

By punching him out like Rulk would. haw-som