Captain Steven Hiller vs. Lieutenant Pete Mitchell

Will Smith's character from Independence day (Captain Steven Hiller) versus Maverick from Top Gun (Lieutenant Pete Mitchell).

Will Smith's character (Hiller) in a F/A-18E/F Super Hornet, Maverick with Merlin in an F-14, both jets fully armed.

They face off in an aerial battle over the rocky mountains....who wins?

I'd say Hiller, hands down. Saving the world from aliens does give him the edge.

Maverick faced down several Migs, cant count him out that easy.