I can think of some logical arguements for revan, but this is strictly freindly, no insults, no heated and angry typing.
1. Didn't bane not learn everything on revan's holocron because he got too scared or something like that? explain this please. Im not sure if its true.
2. Would revan have everything he knew on his holocron?
3. Sith are amaizingly well known for their self overestimating, and Bane worships revan. If revan was not something totally to be worshipped, then why would bane worship him? Remember, this is pre-ro2 bane.
1. Didn't bane not learn everything on revan's holocron because he got too scared or something like that? explain this please. Im not sure if its true.He learned everything, but as of PoD had decided that some of teachings were too dangerous for him to even attempt. No other specifics are provided on that particular matter.
2. Would revan have everything he knew on his holocron?Most likely, unless he made multiple holocrons.
3. Sith are amaizingly well known for their self overestimating, and Bane worships revan. If revan was not something totally to be worshipped, then why would bane worship him? Remember, this is pre-ro2 bane.For the ideology. That's why Bane turned to the ancient Sith: he realized that the Brotherhood was weakening both itself and the power of the Dark side on a larger scale, and sought a way to revitalize the Order in the best manner possible. He found just that in Revan's teachings, along with techniques and rituals that were absent from the Brotherhood's collection.
In duels, bane has superior feats and accomplishments. Kas'im is likely to be better than Malak and anyway the circumstances of that fight are unknown.
In the Force, bane has demonstrated more combat related feats and power levels. the stuff on the holocron was specifically stated to be Sith rituals, not combat techniques.
Bane for all three.
Firstly, Bane was not "scared" of some of the techniques that Revan had knowledge of, he was simply unwilling to use them due to how dangerous they were (which in the case of the Thought Bomb, and possibly others, was outright suicidal).
Secondly, who's to say that Revan would have been any different. People just love to assume that because they were in his holocron, he would have had no problems using them himself, which is bullshit. All that we can say for sure is that Revan had a working knowledge on how to use them (as did Bane afterwards), that's it. The idea that he, unlike Bane, would have been perfectly willing to use such dangerous technique remains completely unsupported. and annoyingly stupid.
Originally posted by HomoSuperior
Firstly, Bane was not "scared" of some of the techniques that Revan had knowledge of, he was simply unwilling to use them due to how dangerous they were (which in the case of the Thought Bomb, and possibly others, was outright suicidal).
Secondly, who's to say that Revan would have been any different. People just love to assume that because they were in his holocron, he would have had no problems using them himself, which is bullshit. All that we can say for sure is that Revan had a working knowledge on how to use them (as did Bane afterwards), that's it. The idea that he, unlike Bane, would have been perfectly willing to use such dangerous technique remains completely unsupported. and annoyingly stupid.
1. Omniscient Narrator: "And soon all his knowledge--his understanding of the dark side--would belong to Bane." - PoD, Page 229.
So there you have the fact that all of Revan's knowledge (dark side and light side), and understanding of the dark side, would belong to Bane. All of it. Not limited to his holocron, but all of it, period.
Then you have the fact that he would soon obtain Nadd's holocron (which contains all of Sadow's knowledge), and has ten years to learn extensively from both sources, with a far greater displayed learning rate than Revan, and really, it's not debatable; Bane's knowledge of the Force shits on Revan's.
2. You completely missed my point, anyway; what I was saying was that there is no proof, whatsoever, that Revan, unlike Bane, actually would have been willing to use those very techniques himself. All that we can say for sure is that Revan had a working knowledge of these techniques, which Bane shares, and apparently people are assuming that Bane's unwillingness to ever use them is specific to him and wouldn't apply to Revan.
Originally posted by HomoSuperior
1. Omniscient Narrator: "And soon all his knowledge--his understanding of the dark side--would belong to Bane." - PoD, Page 229.So there you have the fact that all of Revan's knowledge (dark side and light side), and understanding of the dark side, would belong to Bane. All of it. Not limited to his holocron, but all of it, period.
Then you have the fact that he would soon obtain Nadd's holocron (which contains all of Sadow's knowledge), and has ten years to learn extensively from both sources, with a far greater displayed learning rate than Revan, and really, it's not debatable; Bane's knowledge of the Force shits on Revan's.
Originally posted by HomoSuperior
1. Omniscient Narrator: "And soon all his knowledge--his understanding of the dark side--would belong to Bane." - PoD, Page 229.So there you have the fact that all of Revan's knowledge (dark side and light side), and understanding of the dark side, would belong to Bane. All of it. Not limited to his holocron, but all of it, period.
Then you have the fact that he would soon obtain Nadd's holocron (which contains all of Sadow's knowledge), and has ten years to learn extensively from both sources, with a far greater displayed learning rate than Revan, and really, it's not debatable; Bane's knowledge of the Force shits on Revan's.
2. You completely missed my point, anyway; what I was saying was that there is no proof, whatsoever, that Revan, unlike Bane, actually would have been willing to use those very techniques himself. All that we can say for sure is that Revan had a working knowledge of these techniques, which Bane shares, and apparently people are assuming that Bane's unwillingness to ever use them is specific to him and wouldn't apply to Revan.
Revan holocron was made PRE-kotor so how could Bane learn everything revan knew from kotor on? He couldn't plain and simple. Unless your suggesting that Revan for some reason whent back to lehon accessed his sith holocron(even though he is now a JEDI again) and added everything else he knew.
How cares, its not as if Bane would ever even use lightside techniques any way.
And anyway, the only lightside techniques that Revan could learn in Kotor were anti-driod attck (can't remember name), and Force stasus which Bane has already displayed the ability to Beat ( against Farfalla). Unless Revan suddenly figured out how to use Force sever, then theres not much knowledge that shes gained from KOTOR.
Even if Revan didn't put all her knowledge in the holocron (not provable that she didn't) Bane still has Nadd and Belia's holocrons too use. Occams Razor dictates that Bane probably had a greater knowledge base then Revan.