Tmp was the worst in my opinion. I agree with Kevin Smith in that it's just a slow paced series of glory shots of the enterprise set to Jerry Goldsmith's score. Nemesis sucked because it seemed like the director didn't give a crap about characterization and had never seen star trek. Generations just seemed like an extended episode of the show and didn't really give Kirk a dignified sendoff. IV is kind of ridiculous and I like it but I think it has the absolute worst soundtrack of all the movies, it sounds like a mid 70's hanna barbara cartoon. V wasn't great but I don't think it's the monsterous travesty that everyone says it is because at least it's character driven. I think the new one, despite the excellent reviews may divide a lot of people based on the whole new timeline thing.