Alright:
ScarletSpeed-
+Great animation for first try, original
+I like the effects used on your sig
+Good blending
-A bit too plain
-Not much depth to it
Jboy4-
+Not a bad animation, but could've been better
+Very good blending
+In-depth
-Not very creative text
I liked both signatures very much, and even though ScarletSpeed's attempt at animating was a bit better, Jboy4 made a better sig as a whole. The winner is Jboy4, congrats.