Scott Summers vs Frank Castle in H2H

Started by tkitna3 pages
tkitna Senior Member

Pretty even, but i'd give Frank the majority.

~The Wickerman~ The Evanghelist
Originally posted by Raoul
wild animal

OMFG CHARACTER BASHING FER TEH LEUSE!!!! 👇

durelly

Raoul Hey Yo!

Originally posted by ~The Wickerman~
OMFG CHARACTER BASHING FER TEH LEUSE!!!! 👇

durelly

😆

Batman-Prime Kryptonian Scientist

Frank 8/10

psycho gundam The Nightmare of Solomon

cyclops is good i can agree but castle? he is damn good. one man army good.

frank did make his presents known in ryker's island maximum-security prison, he beat the piss out of like ten lifers that hated his guts. not too sure but they may have had concealed prison shivs to, but i do know that frank was totally unarmed. he wrecked them..

geshien Senior Member
Originally posted by Batman-Prime
Frank 8/10
illadelph12 aka Rakim Illa

I'd go with Frank as he'd more likely fight dirty, necessary or not.

piccolo84 Member

Punisher would destroy Cyclops.

snoopdogg Big Pimpin

Punisher should own Scott I would assume.

redhotrash Senior Member

Cyclops in H2H against Frank? This is nuts, Punisher ripes his throat out after kicking him in the gonads. Or rips off his gonads after kicking him in the throat, depending on the mood.
Real life comparison: Remember that kid in Jr. High who took karate lessons at the mini-mall and bragged about his blackbelt his parents paid for? Remember when he gets destroyed the first day of actual High School then gets home schooled? Same situation here only all grown up.

Drifter Member

Originally posted by redhotrash
Real life comparison: Remember that kid in Jr. High who took karate lessons at the mini-mall and bragged about his blackbelt his parents paid for? Remember when he gets destroyed the first day of actual High School then gets home schooled? Same situation here only all grown up.
Are you comparing training at the X-Mansion with the likes of Wolverine to lessons at the mini-mall? Sure, Castle wins the majority, but I imagine Summers would put up a good fight.

Sado22 Restricted

I'd go with Frank as he'd more likely fight dirty, necessary or not.

the sole reason i'm giving it to Frank. summer's is too much of a nerdy t!t to fight someone like Frank. not to mention that Frank has held his own against DD on several occassions...and the one time they went all the way, Frank was the one who walked away. above all, one main advantage DD has is that frank doesn't want to kill him. if frank ever gets in the killing mood he would have. which is what he showed in their one and only to-the-end brawl which ended with DD with both arms dislocated and sitting there with frank pointing a gun to his head.

Frank 7/10. taking nothing away from summers though. i respect the guy.

comicfan11 Ocean's Heaviest Hitter
Originally posted by illadelph12
I'd go with Frank as he'd more likely fight dirty, necessary or not.

It won't be easy but still the Punisher for a small majority.

jinzin Senior Member
Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Summers' H2H skills are probably not very well known by most people. He surely could beat the crap out of many people. But Punisher? I think that's a bit past him. And he defeated Wolverine without using his powers? Jinzin's head would explode...

Not really, Wolverine was way off his game because he was so badly shaekn by Proteus' hallucinations. This was also at the beginning of Wolverine's career before it was really established to what degree his fighting capacity was at...

He'd never beat Logan straight up sans optic blasts and he's stated as much, but yes, Scott IS a proficient h2h combatant. Good enough to take Castle however? Unlikely.. highly unlikely.

jinzin Senior Member

Originally posted by Juntai
Clops is the leader for a reason.
😄

reasons like having good leadership, and strategic abilities.. not h2h skills that pwn.

Sado22 Restricted

wolverine's feats are so varying. each writer has his own version of what he is and what he's capable of.
i hate that about logan.

BUSTER1 Senior Member
Originally posted by Sado22
wolverine's feats are so varying. each writer has his own version of what he is and what he's capable of.
i hate that about logan.

Too true, but most comic heroes, who have been around for many years, suffer from writing inconsistencies.
Still, Frank for the win.

YFZ 350 Senior Member

Punisher should decimate Cyclops in h2h.

Soljer Beware my Power

Originally posted by Sado22
wolverine's feats are so varying. each writer has his own version of what he is and what he's capable of.
i hate that about logan.

Lulz. Like that doesn't apply to every character ever penned?

norrinradd43 Sentinel of the Spaceways

I think Cyke takes a majority...Extensive danger room training is a definate advantage...Akido and Judo are sound styles to hold black belts in also.