shatterstar vs. silver samurai

Originally posted by Starscream M
based on what? the fact that Silver Samurai gets shatted on by Logan all the time? 🙄

😕

Compared to how Shatterstar fairs against Wolverine, Silver Samurai is practically Superman.

Originally posted by Starscream M
based on what? the fact that Silver Samurai gets shatted on by Logan all the time? 🙄

Unlike Shatterstar, Harada's always dealt out his share of punishment. And we don't know whether or not Shatterstar retained his mutant abilities.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Anyone with a lick of sense could tell you that Silver Samurai would walk all over Shatterstar.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Unlike Shatterstar, Harada's always dealt out his share of punishment. And we don't know whether or not Shatterstar retained his mutant abilities.

Originally posted by cloud102
Silver Samurai is lame. Got his ass punked by black widow. Eat it.

You mean after he stomped Spider-man into the ground, got hit by a car, took a widow bit to the face and then fought Spider-man and Black Widow at the same time?

If you are going to try to make Silver Samurai look bad... you should maybe use an example that... I don't know... makes him look bad?

Originally posted by Starscream M
check the poll...shatterstar is owning silver samurai (whose 2 votes are prob both by you)

I actually voted for Shatterstar by mistake, I'm his seventh vote. 😮

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
I actually voted for Shatterstar by mistake, I'm his seventh vote. 😮

Originally posted by Starscream M
I'm pretty sure the thread maker intended for shatterstar to have his mutant abilities

We're supposed to use current versions unless OP decided otherwise.

Also, I'm pretty sure OP intended for Harada to not be crippled 😬

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW

Also, I'm pretty sure OP intended for Harada to not be crippled 😬

Originally posted by Starscream M
of course he's not crippled for this match

You're the thread starter?

It is not clear as to whether his rarely used mutant abilities were removed after M-Day.

If Shatterstar had all of his powers for this match, it would only be fair for Samurai to use teleportation ring.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
You're the thread starter?

If Shatterstar had all of his powers for this match, it would only be fair for Samurai to use teleportation ring.

His erengy blasts won't make much of a difference, reguardless of the teleportation ring.

Everyone falls before Wolverine. That's hardly an argument.

Originally posted by cloud102
Everyone falls before Wolverine. That's hardly an argument.

Most of them put up a fight. Shatterstar? He just gets folded up like a lawn chair.

Deadpool punked Shatterstar in like two moves also.

Well, if SS had his own book, then maybe he'd put up a scrap.

On the otherhand, you see Wolverine punk people like Vision, New Warriors, Ms, Marvel, various X-Men members and they fold like a lawn chair, too.

Two of the three times Wolverine beat Shatterstar were in X-Force (about as close to Shatterstar book as you can get) and they were both writen by Fabian Nicieza... the guy who created Shatterstar.

Silver Samurai has held his own against Wolverine on a few occasions, he's worked over Spider-man, he's beat a class 70 robot programmed with every known fighting style on earth effortlessly, and he held his own against a dragon until Alpha Flight showed up. Silver Samura would beat Shatterstar down hard and fast.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Silver Samurai has held his own against Wolverine on a few occasions, he's worked over Spider-man, he's beat a class 70 robot programmed with every known fighting style on earth effortlessly, and he held his own against a dragon until Alpha Flight showed up. Silver Samura would beat Shatterstar down hard and fast.

Originally posted by Starscream M
well, just know that you're in the minority in holding that belief

According to the poll. According to the posts in the thread Silver Samurai has more votes.

And you and cloud are both clueless so two of Shatterstars votes mean less than nothing. 😉

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Silver Samurai has held his own against Wolverine on a few occasions, he's worked over Spider-man, he's beat a class 70 robot programmed with every known fighting style on earth effortlessly, and he held his own against a dragon until Alpha Flight showed up. Silver Samura would beat Shatterstar down hard and fast.

Your arguments are strong, now I regret voting for Shatterstar.

Originally posted by Starscream M
well, just know that you're in the minority in holding that belief

The pool results could be different if OP specified what versions we should use.