Originally posted by Kelly_Bean
Most people think Heath Ledger was way too overrated, this is what I think about George Carlin, especially after seeing a lot of you as upset as you are (or are claiming to be).
He was one of the better comedians for sure. Now, he was like 71 already, so I doubt people were as shocked as they were when Heath Ledger died. But I agree with you that often if someone dies, people have a sort of strong reaction to glorify them...probably just some weird sentimentality issue...
That said, George Carlin was great.
Originally posted by Kelly_Bean
Most people think Heath Ledger was way too overrated, this is what I think about George Carlin, especially after seeing a lot of you as upset as you are (or are claiming to be).
Well, now I understand how you felt when Ledger died.
However, in 50+ years of comedy, George gave the world, in my opinion, far, far more than Ledger would have had he lived to be Carlin's age.
Originally posted by Kelly_Bean
Most people think Heath Ledger was way too overrated, this is what I think about George Carlin, especially after seeing a lot of you as upset as you are (or are claiming to be).
Comparing anyones death to anyone elses is just disrespectful and unnecessary in so many ways.
Originally posted by Impediment
Well, now I understand how you felt when Ledger died.However, in 50+ years of comedy, George gave the world, in my opinion, far, far more than Ledger would have had he lived to be Carlin's age.
When it comes to performing, "giving" is subjective. Ledger is like JFK, because he died before anyone could really see how he would turn out. But based on what he did before he died, Heath was a good actor and if he lived to be in his 70's, he no doubt would've had an impressive filmography by then.
Originally posted by Quiero Mota
When it comes to performing, "giving" is subjective. Ledger is like JFK, because he died before anyone could really see how he would turn out. But based on what he did before he died, Heath was a good actor and if he lived to be in his 70's, he no doubt would've had an impressive filmography by then.
I'll agree to that, sir. Very true.
However, I fail to see the JFK comparison.
A George Carlin clip
YouTube video