AS Superman w/PG vs Thanos

Started by darthgoober2 pages

Originally posted by The Great Galen
If we actually were to compare the 2 by feats, Supes on his own has vastly more impressive strength/durability/speed feats then Thanos IMO. AS Supes who was essentially a amped supes by 3 times the powerset could knock a planet into another dimension with a single punch.

Didn't he just knock the planet through a portal or something like that?

thanos gets raped in a nasty way.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Didn't he just knock the planet through a portal or something like that?
He struck the planet so hard that it retreated.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Didn't he just knock the planet through a portal or something like that?

From the scan that Ive seen there was nothing indicating that he pushed it or anything. It just jumped to a entirely different scene. 🙁

as supes 10/10

Originally posted by carver9
From the scan that Ive seen there was nothing indicating that he pushed it or anything. It just jumped to a entirely different scene. 🙁
meh back on topic pg gives supes acces to all the power in existence that coupled with alreadly uber power the amped by the sun=thanos stain on the ground.

Originally posted by Galan007
He struck the planet so hard that it retreated.

Retreated as in BFR'd itself?

Originally posted by darthgoober
Retreated as in BFR'd itself?
Exactly. It retreated from the A/S universe, back to it's own dimension.

Originally posted by Galan007
Exactly. It retreated from the A/S universe, back to it's own dimension.

Is it just me or is that feat far less impressive than it's made out to be by AS Supes's fans...

Originally posted by carnage52
meh back on topic pg gives supes acces to all the power in existence that coupled with alreadly uber power the amped by the sun=thanos stain on the ground.

agreed 10/10

Originally posted by darthgoober
Is it just me or is that feat far less impressive than it's made out to be by AS Supes's fans...
What's impressive is that he struck a planet so hard/injured it so severely, that it felt the need to crawl back to it's own reality [basically BFR'ing itself]. imo, that's an uber feat in itself.

Don't get me wrong, I love A/S Supes - but saying he just "knocked it into another universe with one punch", is a tad overboard, and quite misleading.

May as well post the scans:

Originally posted by Galan007
What's impressive is that he struck a planet so hard/injured it so severely, that it felt the need to crawl back to it's own reality [basically BFR'ing itself]. imo, that's an uber feat in itself.

Don't get me wrong, I love A/S Supes - but saying he just "knocked it into another universe with one punch", is a tad overboard, and quite misleading.

May as well post the scans:


Oh I agree completely about the feat being impressive(I wasn't trying to claim otherwise) I was just pointing out the way it's been skewed to put AS Supes's strength on guys like SBP and Trion Jugg's level.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Oh I agree completely about the feat being impressive(I wasn't trying to claim otherwise) I was just pointing out the way it's been skewed to put AS Supes's strength on guys like SBP and Trion Jugg's level.
👆.

A/S doesn't have the feats to put him over those two, strength-wise. Busting through dimensions, physically > hurting a planet.

For once I can say Supes wins this.

bump