1: Tie or Snake. Jack and the Boss may have developed CQC, but Solid Snake was still said to have been taught in the arts by Big Boss himself, and is shown even past his prime in MGS4 to be every bit as skilled with it as either one agianst the PMCs and even Liquid's FROGS unit, and at his peak, his physical prowess and senses borderlined genetic super soldier.
2: Is the Patriot the only gun they both get? I want to know that before I actually form an opinion on this scenario.
3: Snake. His resources are far more advanced technologically, and his Octocamo muscle suit gives him a huge advantage in the stealth department.
Round 1: The Boss! Whenever Naked Snake and The Boss had a fight for any length of time The Boss would outskill Snake easily, it would be the same With Solid Snake.
Round 2: Snake because he has already shown skill in gunfighting, by killing some very formidable gunfighters.
Round 3: Snake again because of his skills in stealth.
Round 1: The Boss! Whenever Naked Snake and The Boss had a fight for any length of time The Boss would outskill Snake easily, it would be the same With Solid Snake.
Snake>>Boss
Fight One: The Boss
Fight Two: The Boss (If it was a larger arena I'd say Snake could win, if he could use something other than the patriot that is)
Fight tres: Solid Snake, The Boss had a difficult time finding Naked in his more primitive stealth method, Solid has Octocamo so he sneaks up and caps The Boss
I think Snake can still sneak up on her without the Octocamo.
I mean I'm not trying to take anything away from The Boss, but people seem to think Snake can only sneak up on peeps with the octocamo. Which I believe is taking credit away from him since he has been an expert at stealth for a very long time.