homer simpson vs peter griffin

Started by Robtard4 pages

I do now. Simpsons has also been around a lot longer, if we really looked into it, I'm sure there's more Homer punishment feats than there are of Peter's.

How in the world is Peter in better shape though? They both have stomach fat, but Peter clearly has a double (maybe triple) chin.

As far as strength, I vaguely remember Homer doing some pretty (impossible) feats of strength. Can't recall for Peter.

Peter is probably the better skilled combatant though.

Originally posted by Robtard
I do now. Simpsons has also been around a lot longer, if we really looked into it, I'm sure there's more Homer punishment feats than there are of Peter's.

How in the world is Peter in better shape though? They both have stomach fat, but Peter clearly has a double (maybe triple) chin.

As far as strength, I vaguely remember Homer doing some pretty (impossible) feats of strength. Can't recall for Peter.

Peter is probably the better skilled combatant though.

😆 😆 😆

Logical to the bitter end, eh?

So is peter a class 1-10?

Originally posted by dadudemon
😆 😆 😆

Logical to the bitter end, eh?

So is peter a class 1-10?

Huh? Would it be better if I just said "Homer wins, I just like the color yellow better"?

No idea what (system) you mean with "class 1-10"? I'm guessing he's better skilled because he's had more fist fights on screen.

Originally posted by Robtard
Huh? Would it be better if I just said "Homer wins, I just like the color yellow better"?

No idea what (system) you mean with "class 1-10"? I'm guessing he's better skilled because he's had more fist fights on screen.

Oh no, I was underhandedly complimenting you. I just found you approaching this from a very logical standpoint to be humrous. Kind of like debating who has the stinkiest farts based on empirical data or something. I'm not making fun of you, really.

and, yes, I'd have to agree that Peter fights beter than Homer.

However, Homer can take much worse of a beating than Peter could ever dish.

Homer wins this by a land slide without effort, literally.

Originally posted by Robtard
I do now. Simpsons has also been around a lot longer, if we really looked into it, I'm sure there's more Homer punishment feats than there are of Peter's.

How in the world is Peter in better shape though? They both have stomach fat, but Peter clearly has a double (maybe triple) chin.

As far as strength, I vaguely remember Homer doing some pretty (impossible) feats of strength. Can't recall for Peter.

Peter is probably the better skilled combatant though.

H-he played for the New England Patriots.

Peter takes Homer in everything. IMO.

Originally posted by Impediment
Peter takes Homer in everything. IMO.

You can't be serious about 2.

Unless you mean winning is the one that scores less.

Originally posted by Bardock42
You can't be serious about 2.

Unless you mean winning is the one that scores less.

My point exactly. The dumber person is the winner, IMO.

Originally posted by Impediment
My point exactly. The dumber person is the winner, IMO.

Then we agree.

Originally posted by Impediment
Peter takes Homer in everything. IMO.

If you don't give valid reasons why you think so, it's not much of a discussion. Imagine if everyone just said "I think *name* wins, imo", not much of a Vs. debate, might as well make every post a poll.

Originally posted by Bardock42
H-he played for the New England Patriots.

That doesn't counter anything Homer has sustained.

I'd (probably) give it to you, if you'd verify Peter surviving a skyscraper fall.

Originally posted by Robtard
That doesn't counter anything Homer has sustained.

I'd (probably) give it to you, if you'd verify Peter surviving a skyscraper fall.

http://video.yahoo.com/watch/1006634/3803987

About halfway through.

And I think playing as (top) athlete for the Patriots counts as being in pretty ****ing great shape.

Originally posted by Robtard
If you don't give valid reasons why you think so, it's not much of a discussion. Imagine if everyone just said "I think *name* wins, imo", not much of a Vs. debate, might as well make every post a poll.

I think that Peter trumps Homer in every way, is all I meant to say. Peter, allbeit a moron, is, in my opinion, smarter than Homer.

Originally posted by Impediment
I think that Peter trumps Homer in every way, is all I meant to say. Peter, allbeit a moron, is, in my opinion, smarter than Homer.

In the episode "Petarded", it's said that Peter is clinically retarded; just above creationist in fact.

Originally posted by Robtard
In the episode "Petarded", it's said that Peter is clinically retarded; just above creationist in fact.

True, but Homer has a pencil in his brain.

Originally posted by Bardock42
True, but Homer has a pencil in his brain.

So? Doesn't mean he's retarded, like Peter is.

Originally posted by Robtard
So? Doesn't mean he's retarded, like Peter is.

Haha, yeah, I was being humorous, as I stated earlier, it is obvious to me that Peter is more stupid. Homer is just slow and different.

Originally posted by Bardock42
Not sure, didn't Peter fall out of a skyscraper?

He did, but it was when death didn't apply. The Grim Reaper had a twisted ankle at their house and no one could die.

Also Peter became the Grim Reaper in that episode, but it's a feat that Homer had already done.

Also Homer has a crayon in his brain. Pencil just sounds painful!

Homer also survived a fall down Springfield Gorge...twice. Once on a skateboard and once strapped to a stretcher.

Originally posted by Scythe
He did, but it was when death didn't apply. The Grim Reaper had a twisted ankle at their house and no one could die.

Also Peter became the Grim Reaper in that episode, but it's a feat that Homer had already done.

Also Homer has a crayon in his brain. Pencil just sounds painful!

I was referring to the one during the fight with the chicken.

And yeah, I wrote Crayon, but then wasn't sure whether it was the right word.